Spang Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Spang bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for rent in Spang courtesy of Remilitary.com!

How do you feel about vaccinating?

who's talking here?

RoxAnne 1
Renee 4
Kristen 4
Summer 1
Apegrape 1
Tiffanie 1
EPolley06 2
HisWife 2
a3538484uu 1
Pippy 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Renee --- 15 years ago -

Was just reading a blog entry on modernmom.com and looking at the replies. There is a lot of good info in the main topic for those who vaccinate and some good stuff for those agains it in the replies to the article. I've posted the gist of it below.

Vaccinating Your Child Is Like Giving Popeye His Spinach

By Patricia Walters-Fisc... on September 20, 2011

As a mother, health journalist, and former pediatric emergency room nurse, the decision to vaccinate our children was a no brainer.

Caring for children with vaccine-preventable diseases gave me a front line view of just how damaging these diseases can be. Seeing patients with bacterial meningitis, measles, infected chickenpox lesions, and secondary pneumonia from the flu, was enough of an incentive to make sure our children were protected. So when I read a post on ModernMom that mis-interpreted how vaccines cause the body to be imbalanced, I had to respond.

Vaccines strengthen our natural immunity, not knock it out of balance. Think of Popeye. He’s pretty strong and healthy, but now here comes Bluto, beating the stuffing out of him. Things aren’t looking so good for Popeye.

But wait! He gets a taste of spinach and he’s super strong, knocking Bluto out of the park.

This is how vaccines work. By giving our immune system a “taste” of what it’s supposed to be fighting, it can be primed and ready to go when called into action. The author of the post I read reported that vaccines bypass the first line of defense... and he’s right, but what he didn’t report is that the first line of defense is your skin, infection eating cells, and inflammation (swelling). These can’t be trained to fight any specific bacteria or virus. If the vaccines tried to start at this level, they would be ineffective.



Immunizations are soldiers and are supposed to serve as the second line of defense to help mount a quicker attack against a foreign invader. Now when you’re exposed to the flu and you’ve had a flu shot, your body won’t take one to two weeks to produce antibodies. It’ll take days. Not only that, the severity of the illness is far less and you might not even notice any symptoms. Note too, when you receive the flu shot, you might feel yucky for a couple of days - that’s the second line of defense getting primed for action.

Let me make this clear, the vaccines don’t prevent infection, they help your body react more quickly if you are exposed to the virus or bacteria. In fact, you could have been exposed multiple times and never know it because the vaccines are doing their job.

Everyday, people are exposed to millions of bacteria and viruses. On your skin and in your intestine there are one hundred trillion bacterial cells and fungus. (Remember the national debt is around fourteen trillion.) Your body constantly fights these nasties, but they can't fight them all off without help.

Many people think vaccines are only for illnesses other people can give to you, but this isn't true. H. Flu and Pneumococcal bacteria grow naturally in the nose and throat. The Hib and Prevnar vaccines help to protect against overgrowth and invasive illness (meningitis) caused by these bacteria. So not only to immunizations protect against foreign invaders, but also when your body goes haywire. The reduction of bacterial meningitis in children has plummeted since these vaccines were added to the recommended immunization schedule.

I know we all want to believe that these illnesses aren’t here. That all we have to do is eat our fruits and veggies, think happy thoughts, practice good hygiene, and keep our kids around “healthy people” none of us will get sick. I also wish it weren’t necessary to use needles to administer the vaccines. Then the children wouldn’t cry and we wouldn’t feel guilty trying to protect them.

Nature simply doesn’t work that way, but I sure wish it did.


And the rebuff:

I am writing to present a different view. I will be surprised if this does not get deleted because it seems that most mainstream media is financed by big pharma and refuses to even admit the very dangers that the actual physician vaccine inserts
detail. However, if you allow a different view, then I will be glad to see that the media has not been completely bought off and that freedom of speech actually
does exist.

As a pediatric nurse, your credentials are better than most moms, however, I feel that your training and experience are still in the mainstream and buying into the medical mantra that is hard to break out of. Medical science is ever evolving and growing. We must admit that we do not know everything and doctors and scientists do not know everything. I have even read published research showing people with vaccine-induced auto-immune diseases. Clearly we do not know how every individual will react and at what point is one vaccine too many?

Even doctors and researchers openly admit they do not fully understand
how the immune system works and they may not understand the true effects of how vaccines react on the immature infant or even fetal immune system and the neurological side
effects. The list of vaccine ingredients are known allergens for a great many people. People seem hung up on just the Thimerisol but mercury along with aluminum are only two of many ingredients to be worried about. There is the DNA of animals and aborted humans, MSG, antibiotics, dyes, preservatives,anti-foaming agents, Polysorbate 20, 80 and on and on. Anyone can check out the CDC / government website that lists the "known"
ingredients.

The other fact is that we all know many times, unknown pathogens are not
discovered until much later. The medical inserts even state that it is impossible to know or detect these unknown threats. So it’s okay to play Russian roulette? When these viruses are cultured on the DNA of animals and even humans,we cannot guess what DNA gets passed on to our cells. No one does long term research for this. Think the DNA of the old rhesus money, green monkey tissue, bovine tissue, chicken, etc. and how SV-40, AIDS, Avian viruses, etc. have suddenly jumped from these animals into
humans.

I would have never believed that vaccines were dangerous until I suffered vaccine induced encephalitis myself. My mother and brother have had serious reactions as well, so clearly there is a genetic link that disagrees with some ingredient. Vaccines are not perfectly safe and the Supreme Court has even admitted they are drugs that are inherently dangerous. Please stop trying to do the "hard sell" on educated people.
There are definite and clear risks that can outweigh the benefits for more than a small percentage of people. I lived through measles,
mumps, rubella, chicken pox, influenza and even H1N1 yet as an adult, I nearly
died from a “routine” vaccine. So you cannot sugarcoat that these medicines are as safe as "spinach".


and:
"Vaccines strengthen our natural immunity, not knock it out of balance."
This is blatantly incorrect. Anyone reading this, you don't have to believe me but do your research. Vaccinations are usually effective in preventing an individual from manifesting a particular illness, but they do not improve the overall strength or health of the individual nor of the immune system. Instead, vaccinations modify the reactivity of the immune system, decreasing acute discharging inflammatory reactions and increasing the tendency to chronic allergic and auto-immune reactions.

"Your body constantly fights these nasties, but they can't fight them all off without help."
Where exactly are you getting this information? This statement contradicts the the above quoted. How exactly are vaccines making our cell mediated immune system stronger by not letting it do its job? There is no system of the human being, from mind to muscles to immune system, which gets stronger through avoiding challenges, but only through overcoming challenges. When you exercise, do you get stronger if I instead lift the weights for you? I'm not trying to be rude at all but comparing Popeye eating his spinach to giving a child 35 vaccines by age two... Well, no lucid comment on that comparison is possible.

As a former pediatric emergency room nurse, you were exposed to an extreme side that left a lasting impact and that makes perfect sense. However, many individuals have been subjected to the opposite extreme. They have witnessed first hand the heartbreaking results of vaccine injuries on children and that left a lasting impact. Vaccine side effects or the possibility of injury, sadly enough, seems to be an acceptable risk until it happens to your child. Had you witnessed your child seizure within an hour of being vaccinated, then never act "herself" again, and your doctor tells you "No, it had nothing to do with the vaccine." - You may be writing a different article today.

Using vaccines is the way nature is supposed to work, huh?


What do you all think? 

Tiffanie --- 15 years ago -

When it comes to vaccines, I believe the benefits outweigh the risks. Yes, there is a chance your child will have an adverse reaction to a vaccine. My uncle died at the age of 3 from an extreme allergic reaction to the MMR vaccine. However, I do vaccinate my children...including the flu vaccine. 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

We (son and I) the flu vax but will this year since he is going to go to PS soon.

Hubby won't get it since he is not AD anymore unless they tell him he has to 

RoxAnne --- 15 years ago -

Im not going to read this because my son is about to get his 1st set of shots. Im already worried enough :( 

Renee --- 15 years ago -

Sorry everyone, I meant to post this link to the story as well:vaccination article

There is a lot of VERY interesting information in the responses to this article, many from doctors and nurses.

@Roxanne: Sorry, I wasn't trying to fearmonger. I hope all goes well with your babies vaccines, I know from experience that it can be tough! 

HisWife --- 15 years ago -

Not interested, too many unknowns to use my child as a guinea pig! 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

Im not going to read this because my son is about to get his 1st set of shots. Im already worried enough :( 


The one thing you can do is use the extended scheduling for the vax's or whatever they call it. It is where they space them out more and don't ambush them all at once with them. I am not familiar with it completely but I have read about it.

I am going to be SO mad if we get sick after getting our flu shot.

I still may decide not to get the flu shot but our son will get the other ones required for the age 11 set. 

EPolley06 --- 15 years ago -

I personally feel that they way they are given (multiple at a time, even up to 7) is a problem. They are all grouped together to make it easier for patients to be vaccinated quickly. But in reality, wouldn't you want your body to have a chance to adjust to them one at a time? In the future I'm going to space out the vaccinations for my child - that way their body can focus on that particular vaccination - and if there is a negative reaction we can have a better idea of what caused it instead of it just being a big guessing game.

When it comes to autism - I personally believe that people are born with a susceptibility or a marker. Maybe it gets flipped and they become autistic. Maybe it doesn't. I think throwing a big mix of chemicals could be the thing that switches it. Do vaccines cause autism? No - but they may increase the odds of someone who has a marker to show autistic behaviors.... if that makes sense? (Sorry, morning sick today and having trouble getting my thoughts out). 

EPolley06 --- 15 years ago -

The extended or alternate shot schedule is from Dr Sears. That's the one I'm going to follow next time. The trouble is that many of the manufacturers have stopped producing them in individual shots (as opposed to a cocktail of vaccines). Hopefully finding that won't be too much of a problem in Germany.

Here's some information on the alternate scheduling: http://www.askdrsears.com/topics/vaccines/alternative-vaccine-schedule

This gives the breakdown of the regular schedule and the alternate schedule. It is just typed up by someone else - so definitely check it first for accuracy in Dr Sears book.
http://www.mothering.com/community/t/995581/dr-sears-vaccine-schedule 

Apegrape --- 15 years ago -

My son is almost 4 and fully vaccinated (minus flu, we do not do flu). At the age of 1, after his 1 year vaccines he started regressing and showing signs of autism. Around the age of 2 he was diagnosed on the autism spectrum. Now, I am not saying his shots caused his autism ("studies" says it doesn't), but I do believe the could have played a part. My baby girl is almost 9 months, and we were going to go by the Dr. Sears schedule, but after more thought, and research I decide not to vaccinate her until the age of 2, maybe even later. 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

There is something that tells me that we got most of our shots at age 4 or 5 when I was a kid. That was back when there were still dinosaurs though. 

Renee --- 15 years ago -

I agree Kristen - not about the dinosaurs, but about the shots! We got ours when we were around 4 and five. I've read so much now that suggests vaccinations just are not as safe as the powers that be would like us to think they are. I've vaccinated on the longer schedule and we never get flu vaccines. There is a great debate going on in the responses to this blog article that are definitely worth a read if you have the time. 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

where is there a link to the waiver? can you waive just some/one shot but not all?

someone had the waiver on here before......didn't they? 

Summer --- 15 years ago -

The problem with waiting until 4 or 5 to give your child shots is that many of the diseases that we are vaccinated against are most harmful to infants and toddlers. For example, measles in an infant can cause brain damage and severe mental retardation. A healthy four year old will be really sick but has a good chance of a full recovery. I think that vaccinations are a good idea for any child but especially in Europe where children have a better chance of coming in contact with someone who may been exposed. In the US measles, mumps and polio are fairly rare but in countries as close as Slovenia and Romania they are still very common. While children have little to no chance of contact with these diseases in small town USA, there is a very real chance here. If people are willing to play russian roulette with their kids health that is their decision but I am not one of those people. 

HisWife --- 15 years ago -

If people are willing to play russian roulette with their kids health that is their decision but I am not one of those people.

I think russian roulette can be applied to both sides of the argument. It's a case of, you're damned if you do, and you're damned if you don't. :) 

a3538484uu --- 15 years ago -

My feeling has always been that giving a newborn, or very young baby multiple vaccinations can be extremely risky. Dr. Sears has a great book called The Vaccine Book that proposes an alternative schedule which recommends one shot at a time spaced out over more years. The child still ends up fully vaccinated, but on a different timeline. His alternative schedule can also be found online (google it). 

Renee --- 15 years ago -

I also espouse Dr. Sears's schedule. It seems to balance the best of both. The child is fully vaccinated, but is not bombarded with the combo vaccines that are really at the heart of the safety debate. Summer, there is really a very interesting debate on the issue below the article that I posted that gives a lot of very good information regarding the risks of vaccines. I'm not suggesting people should never vaccinate, I'm just suggesting that there are things about vaccinating that are unknown and unsafe (like the fact that they can in rare cases, cause seizures and encephalitis - and this has been directly related to the multi-vaccines) and the government is ignoring those things in the interest of making vaccinations easier and faster. The problem is that they may not fully understand the repercussions. For instance, there has been a huge increase in cases of ADHD since the combo vaccinations came into use and there is evidence that the two may be related, but the connection has never been studied. The alternate side of this is that people's fear and uncertainty can also cause false information to spread, like the relation between Autism and vaccines. Until our government puts a lid on the power plays of the big pharma companies and does some serious research into the effects of vaccines on infants and children, I am going to remain wary. As for the flu vaccine, there is a LOT of evidence that it does more harm than good and we do not use it.

Kristen, I'm not sure about a link to the waver form, or for which vaccines it is valid. I have only used it for the flu vaccine. Just contact the nurse at the school and she can give you all the info you need. She is really helpful! 

Pippy --- 15 years ago -

I agree with Summer.
My children have all of their vaccinations and any children I may have in the future will be the same. I am not going to chance my child getting a serious disease. Even if some shot gave my child autism (which studies have shown it doesn't, and the person who originally did the study admitted to messing with the testing) I would rather have a child with autism than a dead child or very sick child.
I have a friend who does each shot a week apart. I respect that but I personally would rather get it all over with. That way my children are only in pain once rather than 4 or 5 seperate times. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

parenting

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Spang Underground