Spang Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Spang bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for rent in Spang courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Parenting Tips

who's talking here?

M'lissa 2
Kristen 5
Spangalang 4
Ilumine 2
EPolley06 2
HisWife 2
J3nWTFOMG 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

J3nWTFOMG --- 15 years ago -

I'm at the end of my rope...

My three girls are 8, 3, and 9 months.

My 3 yr old is my current "problem." NOTHING makes her happy. She can spend an entire day outside with her sister, and the next day we give her sister some "alone" time and she freaks out and wails because she isn't allowed back out.

She wakes up and wants Playhouse Disney... We put it on, but she walks off, and wails whe her sister changes it to HER channel...

Any solutions for "middle child" syndrome?! I was an only child, and my husband was the oldest - so we're having a tough time drawing the line between sense and nonsense! 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

I only know a few middle children and if it makes you feel any better they are very sane and successful and appear to be happy as adults.

I know that does not help much but.......maybe it is just her personality or her age--not a birth order thing? 

J3nWTFOMG --- 15 years ago -

Doesn't help ANY Kristen ;) Thanks though.... 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

Ok, actual advice. Ignore it. Send her to her room when she wails tell her she can come out when she acts human 

HisWife --- 15 years ago -

The consequences/punishment must outweigh the pleasure she gets from acting inappropriately. It sounds to me as if she has the attitude of 'entitlement'. Take EVERYTHING away (TV, outside) for a week or so then slowly introduce it back one-by-one, reminding her that all fun and entertainment CAN and WILL be taken away if she can't handle it (act appropriately). After all, there's nothing wrong with her sitting in her room with a few choice toys--or none for that matter--if that's what it must come to! 

M'lissa --- 15 years ago -

I think its her age not her place in the family. My almost 3 yr old is the same sometimes and she's the oldest. She was an only child until 4mnths ago. I'm sure your daughter will grow out of it. 

J3nWTFOMG --- 15 years ago -

A whole week without TV or outside seems extreme for 3.5. (not only that, but that's more punishment for me than for her!)

I realize it's a phase, and she'll get better... but I think it would just be nice if I had some sort of rational way to deal with it other than yelling - because that's what it has come to. She just doesn't react to ANYTHING! 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

I still would let her yell in her own room. Does she dislike being separated from the rest of the family ? Most kids do at that age, they don't like to be put in their rooms and isolated. If she is fine being isolated then I am not sure what to suggest. If that works then when she comes out I would--

Then make her apologize, ask her why she lost her temper. Ask her what she could have done differently. Maybe she can solve her own problem that way?

If not, I get the whole 'feeling grounded when your kid is grounded' thing...........I hate it. I don't like having to be punished myself when he is grounded. 

J3nWTFOMG --- 15 years ago -

Wish I could pinpoint it... Ava's a creation all her own! 

HisWife --- 15 years ago -

Extreme?? You'd be surprised at how quickly they learn! I completely agree that it is torture for you, but remember it is not about you, it is about teaching your child. (Trust me, I've had my share of torture for x amount of days, but I'm still reaping the benefits long after).

I heard it once said that when it comes to correcting our children, we as parents must be willing to go just one step further than they are!

You can wait until she outgrows it, but why wait and lose your sanity in the process. Teach her now and not only will you have your voice and your sanity but you'll also enjoy her more! 

EPolley06 --- 15 years ago -

My best advice - ignore it, punish it (with time outs), and then give her positive attention when she's behaving appropriately. It's a tough age anyway - and then trying to get her to socialize appropriately and learn various rules is hard. But - whatever you do, be consistent. That'll be the most important that she learns when she does A, B will happen EVERY time. 

EPolley06 --- 15 years ago -

A whole week without TV or outside seems extreme for 3.5. (not only that, but that's more punishment for me than for her!)

I wouldn't do it for a full week, especially at that age. My daughter is 3.5 years old, but an only child so far. One day is the most we do at a time - I don't think they understand the connection between why they can't have something and their behavior for as long as a week.

For example - If I ask her to clean her room and she doesn't. I tell her "Okay, whatever mommy picks up, mommy keeps." Then anything I pick up without her helping to clean her room - I take into my room for 24 hours. Then when I give it back I ask why it's been in my room and we talk about it what she can do to keep her toys. This has been really helpful. It keeps her accountable and remembering the consequences.

Good luck! 

Spangalang --- 15 years ago -

I don't think they understand the connection between why they can't have something and their behavior for as long as a week.

It's kind of funny because when my older ones are grounded from something (i.e. TV or outside), my 3.5 year old has no problem recollecting and reminding them that they can't do A because they did B.

If she can make the connection when it comes to her older siblings, I'm pretty darn sure she can make the connection when it effects her personally. :) 

Spangalang --- 15 years ago -

When I'm at your frustration point, my rule of thumb is: STOP TALKING AND DO! (At this point, actions speak louder than words) 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

I think kids are much smarter than we give them credit for. Much more able to do more than we think also.

Cannot talk about schools dumbing kids down if we do the same thing at home.

Just sayin' 

Spangalang --- 15 years ago -

Well said, Kristen! 

Ilumine --- 15 years ago -

We use a variety of punishments for the variety of behaviors - match the punishment to the crime to be more effective.

My DD throws toys, in both frustration and in play. Punishment is the removal of the toy till the next day.

Whining / begging / that perpetual please when I have said no, gets a time out AWAY from the family (the whole point of the whaling is to either try to wheedle mom or punish mom for not giving in, so being far away from Mom ruins it)

DD runs away from us, usually toward a busy street. Punishment is to either lock her down in the stroller (which we still have JUST for punishments sake) or we immediately go home.

Be creative. 

Ilumine --- 15 years ago -

However, you also need to be PROACTIVE in your parenting.

Do you honestly think that locking your 3 yo inside, while your older child gets to play outside is the right thing? I recognize wanting to give each child personal time, but the outside should not be one of those places.

The outside is where you send them to get them out of your hair and to work off the energy that they, as kids, can't control yet.

And my suggestion for the tv time is an actual timer. Buy a tv specific timer. Everyone gets 30 mins, whether they are watching or not. And once the alarm goes off, the next kid gets her time.

Then it goes off. That way the temptation is gone and they have nothing to fight over. This has been MY saving grace with my 2 1/2 yo. The amount of fighting, whining and all over crankiness has just dropped when I started timing her tv time.

She is going to start being able to "earn" more tv time in the future...positive reinforcement. 

Spangalang --- 15 years ago -

The problem with being creative is, what happens in the absence of those props (e.g. stroller, timer, etc.)?

Are we not treating the symptoms instead of the problem? The problem is that they have not learned to CONTROL themselves. 

M'lissa --- 15 years ago -

Kristen that is what I do. When M'kayla freaks out I put her in her room to calm down not really a time out just a break from each other. When she calms down she can come out and apologize and talk about what her problem is. 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

Kristen that is what I do. When M'kayla freaks out I put her in her room to calm down not really a time out just a break from each other. When she calms down she can come out and apologize and talk about what her problem is.


aww, our kids should meet and get married, they will be good communicators, lol! they can talk to each other about everything :) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Spang Underground