Spang Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Spang bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for rent in Spang courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Amazon pedophilia author arrested

who's talking here?

RoxAnne 1
Rachel 5
Renee 9
Marco 1
Kristen 2
Jaymee 1
itsme 1
Girl from the south 1
LaurenB 5
J3nnif3r 17
badstreetusa 11
Jason 24
Coricca 4
lagjeg 1
georgebush 12

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Renee --- 15 years ago -

Just Disgusting

My view on this is that this man should be hung out to dry, and anyone who purchased his "guide" should be too. Free speech my a$$ 

Kristen --- 15 years ago -

OMG that is crazy 

Jason --- 15 years ago -

Free speech is a funny thing. It's easy to love it until you hear something you don't like. 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

C'mon Jason, an outline of how to successfully molest a child goes beyond free speech. It is a step-by-step guide of how to victimize a child. The protection of the child supercedes his right to free speech. 

Renee --- 15 years ago -

Jason, I don't think it's really about "something you don't like". I support free speech, even to the point of letting KKK have their street rallies etc, despite the fact that they completely sicken me. But this, this is just completely heinous in every respect - there is absolutely no excuse, exception, argument, or circumstance in which any human being should be legally able to write about, take pictures of, look at pictures of, or take part in child molestation, rape, or pornography. Period. We are human beings, we have the ability to reason and we have a moral compass and we absolutely MUST draw the line somewhere. 

RoxAnne --- 15 years ago -

I personally am surprised that Amazon agreed to put the book back for sell. They pulled it once why not just leave it alone? Are they really going to make that much money off it?
I mean if I owned a book store, I would not carry that book. 

Jason --- 15 years ago -

I don't think it can have pictures in it legally. I don't think it can discuss real events legally. If it discusses the issue in an abstract form there is no way it cannot be free speech. Certainly it is offensive, but how offensive something is is not how free speech is measured. 

badstreetusa --- 15 years ago -

how offensive something is is not how free speech is measured

Exactly... 

Renee --- 15 years ago -

The bottom line is that this man was not only promoting child rape and molestation, but giving directions how how it should be done without getting caught. I honestly don't give a rats a$$ about free speech in this case. 

J3nnif3r --- 15 years ago -

Too bad it couldn't have been part of some type of sting operation... You know - keep tabs on the people who actually purchase the book! 

Renee --- 15 years ago -

Agreed Jen. 

badstreetusa --- 15 years ago -

Yes, although I agree with the free speech, I strongly agree that this animal should be punished...unfortunately it's a slipperly slope, but I think we'll see him prosecuted. 

lagjeg --- 15 years ago -

Too bad the police can't hook up with Kindle and find out what creeps actually downloaded/bought the book. 

Jason --- 15 years ago -

It's tough seeing so many people who are so opposed to free speech. 

Jaymee --- 15 years ago -

"Amazon believes it is censorship not to sell certain books simply because we or others believe their message is objectionable. Amazon does not support or promote hatred or criminal acts, however, we do support the right of every individual to make their own purchasing decisions." from an article in MSMBC.com

Who still shops from Amazon.com? They have the right to publish this book and you have the right to financially impact them by never shopping with Amazon again. I realize that Amazon removed the book with much criticism, but If you are truley outraged then make your individual purchasing decisions elsewhere. 

Girl from the south --- 15 years ago -

Okay, isn't it true that yelling "FIRE" in a theater isn't considered "free speech" because of the harm/chaos it can create?
So the full intention of this book is to harm another. Does it really fall under free speech? Would a step-by-step guide to murder be okay? I would hope not.

Just a funny side note -- I typo-ed in the first line...instead of FIRE I typed FRIES....that might not be okay to yell in a crowded theater as well. 

Renee --- 15 years ago -

You can be as "free speech" as you want Jason, but there are some cases in which there really are no excuses or exceptions, and this is one of them. I get sooooo tired of the ultra-liberalism in our country trying to pass off the idea that anything and everything is ok; when to say 'no' to something is automatically criticized as 'judgemental'. You can take the 'live and let live' concept too far! 

Jason --- 15 years ago -

During World War I, the US government jailed those who were distributing anti-draft pamphlets. Schenck, the publisher of the pamphlet, was convicted, and his conviction was upheld by the Supreme Court in 1919. (This decision was the source of the well-known "fire in a theatre" quote.)

Holmes, writing for a unanimous majority, ruled that it was illegal to distribute flyers opposing the draft during World War I. Holmes argued this abridgment of free speech was permissible because it presented a "clear and present danger" to the government's recruitment efforts for the war. Holmes wrote:
The most stringent protection of free speech would not protect a man falsely shouting fire in a theater and causing a panic. [...] The question in every case is whether the words used are used in such circumstances and are of such a nature as to create a clear and present danger that they will bring about the substantive evils that Congress has a right to prevent.
Holmes wrote of falsely shouting fire, because, of course, if there were a fire in a crowded theater, one may rightly indeed shout "Fire!"; one may, depending on the law in operation, even be obliged to. Falsely shouting "Fire!" in a crowded theater, i.e. shouting "Fire!" when one believes there to be no fire in order to cause panic, was interpreted not to be protected by the First Amendment.
The First Amendment holding in Schenck was later overturned by Brandenburg v. Ohio, which limited the scope of banned speech to that which would be directed to and likely to incite imminent lawless action (e.g. a riot). The test in Brandenburg is the current High Court jurisprudence on the ability of government to proscribe speech after that fact. Despite Schenck being limited, the phrase "shouting fire in a crowded theater" has since come to be known as synonymous with an action that the speaker believes goes beyond the rights guaranteed by free speech, reckless or malicious speech, or an action whose outcomes are blatantly obvious.

A basic overview of Brandenburg v. Ohio shows us that: "The U.S. Supreme Court reversed Brandenburg's conviction, holding that government cannot constitutionally punish abstract advocacy of force or law violation. The unanimous majority opinion was per curiam (issued from the Court as an institution rather than as authored and signed by an individual justice). The earlier draft had originally been prepared by Justice Abe Fortas before he was forced to resign in the midst of an ethics scandal, and would have included a modified version of the clear and present danger test. In finalizing the draft, Justice Brennan eliminated all references to it, substituting instead the "imminent lawless action" language.[2] Justices Black and Douglas concurred separately."

You can read more on this here

Sedition Act of 1918 http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sedition_Act_of_1918

Schenk v. United States http://www.infoplease.com/us/supreme-court/cases/ar37.html

and

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Schenck_v._United_States

Brandenburg v. Ohio http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brandenburg_v._Ohio



Here is a websites listing books that have been banned at some point or another in one or more US libraries because they were offensive:

http://www.adlerbooks.com/banned.html


This is an article from CNN.com discussing the authors recent arrest:

http://edition.cnn.com/2010/CRIME/12/22/florida.obscenity.arrest/


Renee, you say this is one of those cases where there are no excuses or exceptions, but you don't explain why, please explain.

How offensive material is isn't the barometer of free speech. Freedom of speech isn't to provide protection to popular speech but instead it was expressly designed to protect unpopular speech. 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

I would say that a step-by-step account of how to molest a child, a terrible, illegal act, fits both definitions you provided:

The question in every case is whether the words used are used in such circumstances and are of such a nature as to create a clear and present danger that they will bring about the substantive evils that Congress has a right to prevent.

limited the scope of banned speech to that which would be directed to and likely to incite imminent lawless action

Though I understand the second is most often used in reference to a riot, I believe the author's work could definitely be interpreted to likely incite lawless action. A person maybe thinking about committing this crime in an abstract, fantasy way now is provided a very real means to do it.

Even if you don't believe this argument would win out in court, how could you argue that a company such as Amazon should sell the book? There are many books that they don't carry, for one reason or another. I would even suggest that they did allow it not because of any belief in "free speech," but because their marketing dept. knew it would be controversial, which would bring ppl to the site. Any press is good press. 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

Actually, I just read that his charge has to do with sending obscene material through the mail, a crime in Florida. Yes, they may have stretched some things to make that happen, but hey, if they are in the boundaries of the law...

We have a flawed legal system. Pretty much everyone knows this. It would be impossible to have a perfect one. But at some point, decency has to step in:

Officials said the book talks about safe sex and avoiding injury to children, grooming and preparing children for sex and teaching children how to lie to their parents.

Judd said Greaves' book outlines a "code of ethics" that shows pedophiles how to look for the most vulnerable children.
 

Jason --- 15 years ago -

Rachel what is decency? What you consider decent could be very different from what others consider decent. This is why we have a constitutionally protected freedom of speech. As I said before how obscene something is is not the test used to determine if something is protected by freedom of speech. This cannot be an issue about decency. It's absolutely repulsive to me to discuss child molestation, but I don't have to participate in that discussion. That's the beauty of free speech. Don't read it. Don't listen.

I see you read the article so you must have read this part "Greaves, who was arrested in Colorado on Monday, said the book, "The Pedophile's Guide to Love and Pleasure: A Child-Lover's Code of Conduct," can be used as a guide to rehabilitating pedophiles. And, instead of teaching them how to avoid arrest, it teaches them to avoid illegal actions, he said."

The author himself says that he was a victim of phedophelia for many years and then participated in it. He said his hope is that the book helps pedophiliacs reform.


""This has nothing to do with free speech and everything to do with obscenity," Judd said (Polk County Sheriff). "We had a law in Florida that applied. We only needed jurisdiction."" 

J3nnif3r --- 15 years ago -

Jason... ShuuuuuuuUUuuUUUUut UP! (there's my freedom of speech!) 

Jason --- 15 years ago -

LOL you are an idiot J'nnifer. 

J3nnif3r --- 15 years ago -

As are you Jason. 

Renee --- 15 years ago -

Jason, I believe I've already stated my opinion in clear terms. I will not continue to argue when you clearly intend to play devil's advocate in this case. You asked Rachel, "What is decency" Certainly, we all have our ideas about what is and is not decent, acceptable, etc., but there are also some things that all people (except those operating outside the law) find indecent. This is one of them. Decency is subjective of course, but I can guarantee it includes keeping children safe from pedophiles. 

Jason --- 15 years ago -

Decency is not a legal term. My point is that your definition of decency is different from someone else's. I had included a link to a website that lists books that have been banned in libraries in the US just so you could see that some peoples idea of decent is different from others.

You might not feel that his book is indecent (I do) but the point is you don't have to buy it. He is free to express his weird ideas, and you are free to not have to pay attention to them. 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

It is not so subjective, Jason. What he sent through the mail legally qualifies as obscene under Florida law. Nothing subjective about that; decency had been given a legal definition there. That is why they set up the sting operation through that state. 

Renee --- 15 years ago -

Jason, I fully understand the point you are trying to make, and I give you all due respect for arguing intelligently and calmly, but in this case, I simply do not have room for compromise. 

Jason --- 15 years ago -

What is obscene and what isn't has been a very old dbate in the United States. Ask yourself this, is a naked body obscene when displayed in public? If so would you concider Michelangelo's David obscene (often argued as one of the finest sculptures in the world)? So it suddenly becomes an issue of taste and context and not subject material.

When judging a document or item as obscene the US supreme court has proposed the "Miller Test" in an attempt to determine if something could legally be defined as obscene. (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miller_test). While it could be argued that Greave's book fails two parts of the test, it cannot be declared entirely void of litterary value as it is a self help book and therefor passes the "Miller Test."

Florida Code offiers this definition of obscene :

(10) "Obscene" means the status of material which:
(a) The average person, applying contemporary community standards, would find, taken as a whole, appeals to the prurient interest;
(b) Depicts or describes, in a patently offensive way, sexual conduct as specifically defined herein; and
(c) Taken as a whole, lacks serious literary, artistic, political, or scientific value. (http://law.justia.com/florida/codes/2009/TitleXLVI/chapter847/847_001.html)

which you can see is the same as the "Miller Test,"

Renee, I understand you don't have any room to compromise your morals. It's entirely fine of you not to compromise your morals, and I wouldn't want you to, but since we all have different moral standards we are fortunate to have have the rule of law and the constitution to remove the burden of having to apply our moral values on others. 

Rachel --- 15 years ago -

I don't know, seems to me it fits all three definitions of obscene. The author claims it is a rehabilitation manual; none of the law officials involved interpret it that way. 

page 1 2 3 4
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Spang Underground