Spang Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Spang bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for rent in Spang courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Parenting Advice Needed

who's talking here?

Shanna 1
Rachel 1
Renee 1
Kayla 1
Kristen 4
Jaymee 1
J3nnif3r 6
badstreetusa 3
Jason 1
Kristie 2
Tiffanie 1
Cheryl 2
kari 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

J3nnif3r --- 16 years ago -

ok not really parenting, but I wanted some different opinions on something that I can't decide on...

My middle daughter is 3, and still has a blankie. She used to have it with her ALL the time, and I've managed to restrict it to only while she's in her bed. Occasionally, she'll retreat to her room, grab it out of her dresser drawer and kind of chill on her own for a bit... She sucks her thumb with blankie, for comfort.

I've read many a forum that suggests against taking blankie away. They say that it's a child's source of comfort, and that the child will stop using it when they're ready. But isn't that true for EVERYTHING in life? Perhaps I'll give up chocolate chip cookies when I'm ready! (after all, there's nothing that soothes me like comfort food!)

I'd like to plan a way to break her of the blankie forever! I've tried tricking her into thinking we trashed it... She didn't buy it. I tried telling her it was in the dirty clothes, nope... she insisted on having it back. If we don't give it to her at bedtime, she just lays in bed and cries for it (and it breaks my heart, the darn sucker I am!)

What is your opinion? Anyone gone through similar experience? 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

We had a blankie and found out it was the fabric he liked, not so much the blankie.....so we got a 2nd one, just to see if that one would 'work' too.....it was actually the jersey kinda pillow cases not a blankie

anyhow

it was the fabric, so slowly, we cut it smaller and smaller.....till it was the size of a hankie.........then he eventually lost interest in it on his own, but the size of it was part of the problem

if he wanted to keep it till he was 99 I would not have cared, it was that it was bulky and a pain to carry around.....

I still sleep with a stuffed animal.....my BFF does too, she even carries it in her carry on with her

I don't even see any harm in a comfort object, if I had something STILL that helped me fall asleep easily and it was a simple as a blankie, I would be soooooo happy. 

J3nnif3r --- 16 years ago -

It's the thumbsucking that accompanies the blanket that bothers me. She's wearing a rough spot on her thumb! I know if I got rid of the blankie, then the thumbsucking would disappear too.

I'm afraid to do it right now, just because she's going through so much already with the new baby in the house, but I'm seriously thinking of cutting it cold turkey after a couple more months... when life in the house has calmed to a routine norm.

The size is nothing - it's just one of those small, square blankies with the little animal head on top. Silk on one side, fuzzy on the other. Her grandmother bought it for her at some store in Belgium. We'll definitely save it :) 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

plus, it is only at night, and she is only three

if there were not cookies or telephones to call someone and rant, or hmm......yeah more cookies, I would probably suck my thumb for comfort.......lol 

J3nnif3r --- 16 years ago -

:) Good point. 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

sorry 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

this is the thing, I am going through this phase where I am thinking the American family is deteriorating, and I just wish kids could be little for a bit longer, and not just be gone........all the time, and be all grown up, then poof no one knows where it all went 

Jaymee --- 16 years ago -

I agree with Kristen she is only three. 

Kristie --- 16 years ago -

My neice was about 4 when she "lost" her blankie. She always lost it around the house so one day my sister finds it when she wasn't around and hid it in the top of the closet where my neice couldn't find it. She let her look for it and when she couldn't find it she cried but it only lasted a night or two. Maybe get a big blanket and trade it for her little one. Then it can just be her blanket. I don't know really. Thats what my parents did. When I was little I had a rag that I carried and my grandma got me a bigger blanket and traded me. I loved it since I could actually get warm by it. Now it hangs in my sons room. 

J3nnif3r --- 16 years ago -

That's why I asked for opinions :D I'm with you Kristen - I do push for my children to be independent and "big" and they ARE! And it's awesome... but I look at Baby V and think, where did my other babies go!? I don't remember them ever being so small :( 

J3nnif3r --- 16 years ago -

@Kristie - I DID buy a big blanket, of the same material that the little blankie is made of. She refused it. (now it belongs to the new baby) hehe...

I DID find blankie, out of Ava's room earlier... it was in my bedroom floor, so I hid it. I know I'll give in and give it back, but it'll be interesting to watch her look for it later! 

Tiffanie --- 16 years ago -

All 3 of my older boys were blankie kids. The older two stopped using theirs around 5 or 6 and my 4 year old still has his. I think it's something they'll retire once they're ready. I wouldn't rush it. 

Kristie --- 16 years ago -

Yea, I guess I should add I had mine till I got into kindergarden. In pre-K I had to bring it with me to school, it was that bad. I still slept with it until I was in Jr. high along wth my teady bear I slept with till highschool. I still would if my husband wouldn't object. 

Jason --- 16 years ago -

Are you sure you didn't replace your blanie with cookies?

Let her have her blankie. Don't let her spend her life trying to subconsciously fill the void that was left by blankie. 

Kayla --- 16 years ago -

My almost 5 year old has had his "busy bear"-a little blankie with a bear attached), since he was a newborn. He used to want it ALL the time, but he's weening himself off of it. A lot of nights now he doesn't even realize he has it. Sometimes if he's sick or exceptionally tired, he asks for it or purposely find it, but I really think they eventually ween themselves off the blankie. There's nothing wrong with a little comfort! 

badstreetusa --- 16 years ago -

Don't worry about the blankie. To stop the thumb sucking, put a band aid on her thumb. That's what we did and it broke our son. 

Shanna (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

Jennifer,
Sophie and Hannah are blankie babies...They will grow out of it! Sophie left hers in the airport on base when we were traveling to the states last year. She was old enough to realize that she had to hold on to it if she wanted it. Once we were in the air and she wanted to take a nap but her bobo was missing she was sad. I hated it for her but I told her she did it. If she wanted it she should have grabbed. She is old enough to realize and understand the situation. She whined the first few times she napped or went to bed and then she never brought it up again. She knew she left it in the airport back home and she may never see it again. Believe it or not she did great without it! Now she likes to sleep with different blankies and is not so partial to a specfic one! Although it made for a terrible situation it all worked out for the best.
I guess what I am saying is that she is still young! In a year or two she will be old enough and able to understand different situations better. She will suprise you one day. I would just let her be comforted by her blankie for now. She will eventually grow out of it. 

Rachel --- 16 years ago -

I pretty much agree with everybody that she will grow out of the blanket when she's ready, but I totally understand your thumbsucking concern. That can become a very bad situation if it continues.

My son has a special blanket, but he never took it everywhere, and is fine if it's in the wash instead of his bed at night. For us, it was breaking him of the pacifier- similar to the thumb sucking. I think trading her blanket for something, a BIG GIRL thing, would be something to try.
I showed Trae pics of a friend's new baby. The baby was crying in a few pics. I told Trae he was crying because he didn't have a paci. So we talked about sending Trae's to him. This convo went on for about a week, also discussing how he was a big boy, big boys didn't uses pacis, etc. We also had a new baby at the time, so I didn't want to do too much change, but I used the baby as an example- the baby uses a paci, not you, etc. Then I also talked about a special big boy item he wanted, and said he could have it when he wasn't a baby anymore, ie., no paci. So after about a week, he agreed to send his pacis, packed in an envelope, to the new baby.
He was a little anxious that first night, but no big fit or anything. 

Cheryl --- 16 years ago -

I agree with most of the ladies that at this age I probably wouldn't stress much about the blankie. As for the thumbsucking... I know it can start to cause issues, but if you don't make a big deal about it they tend to outgrow that as well. My little boy sucks on two fingers and has since he was little (refused the paci even as a tiny baby in favor for those same two fingers). He was getting marks on his fingers and there were concerns it could affect his teeth as well. However, we tried not to make a big deal of it. If I saw him doing it I would casually mention that the dentist told him it was bad for his teeth, or I would point out the sores on his fingers. It seems to be working... I think the only time he does it now is if he is extremely tired. He just turned three.

One thing I saw was the suggestion about the bandaid. I would probably not use that option. Bandaids are a choking hazard if swallowed and putting one on the thumb a child sucks on seems like a recipie for disaster. Besides, I watched my parents do everything in the world to get my sister to stop and it just made her do it that much harder. 

badstreetusa --- 16 years ago -

One thing I saw was the suggestion about the bandaid. I would probably not use that option. Bandaids are a choking hazard if swallowed and putting one on the thumb a child sucks on seems like a recipie for disaster.

Nice assumption...of course we didn't do it while he was sleeping. And we supervised our child...the bandaid was on in such a way he couldn't easily remove or swallow it. It only took a couple of days to break him.

Just because your parents' efforts didn't work, doesn't mean there aren't solutions out there. 

kari --- 16 years ago -

My grandma told me a story about my dad who sucked his thumb only while he had his blanket. When he was a little over three she started talking about how when he's older he won't need his blanket... after about 6 months of this discussion she changed all his bed sheets/blankets, ect. and told him it was time to change the blanket too. She said it took him only one night of tossing and turning and after that he never sucked his thumb again because the blanket was gone also.
That being said...being a military kid is hard, things change a lot, and like you said there is a new baby. If it were my kid I'd just wait it out :) 

Cheryl --- 16 years ago -

I did not assume anything. I mentioned nothing about him/her having a bandaid on while sleeping, nor any level of supervision that you did or did not provide. I am glad it worked for you and that you thought to supervise.

Regardless, not everyone reading the suggestion would think of the potential for choking so I felt it needed to be put out there. Perhaps not for the original poster, but maybe for someone else considering this option that had NOT thought of the potential hazard. It is not a judgement on your parenting, merely an observation.

You are also correct that just because something didn't work for my parents doesn't mean "something" out there might work. I guess I just went for a less direct and potentially less confrontational approach with my young son and explained to him why it was better for him not to suck on his fingers and it worked for him. Not that this method would work for everyone either, after all... if the same things worked for everyone she wouldn't have asked for advice in the first place because we would all have the answers by now. =) 

J3nnif3r --- 16 years ago -

We did try the bandaid when her sore got really bad... It was kind of chapped, a big, hard scab type sore. I'd put neosporin (however you spell that) on the sore to kind of lube it up and then cover it with a bandaid and put her to bed. She'd still suck on the thumb, and miraculously, the bandaid would still be on in the morning.

I didn't bother hiding the blanket tonight. I went straight to where I put it and got it for her and tucked her into bed. She was upset because she couldn't stay awake with her big sister and her sister's friend who is sleeping over. I said ya know, lemme grab blankie and I'll come read you a book before bed. It was 9pm, she hadn't had a nap - and I knew that getting through a book with her was going to be a struggle too! It took about 5 minutes after lights out for her to close her eyes and snore :)

I think all of you have wonderful points of view on this. And Cheryl, you're totally right for posting on the choking hazard. MOST of us have common sense, but there's the few out there who need to be told. I'm sure those few are also the ones who need warning labels on microwaves that read "don't place small children in here." LOL! 

badstreetusa --- 15 years ago -

I think all of you have wonderful points of view on this. And Cheryl, you're totally right for posting on the choking hazard. MOST of us have common sense, but there's the few out there who need to be told. I'm sure those few are also the ones who need warning labels on microwaves that read "don't place small children in here." LOL! .

Yeah, that's what I failed to realize in my rant; common sense isn't so common. 

Renee --- 15 years ago -

Just to add my two cents: I had a blankie when I was little. I was pretty attached to it, though mostly used it at bedtime. I gave it up when I was about 8, on my own. It was so raggedy and old and full of holes that I just figured it was done for and threw it away! My daughter, who is 5, has a blankie she sleeps with. I wouldn't dream of taking it away. First, she's 5, not 25, and second, there really isn't anything bad about it other than that it is bulky when we travel. As for the thumb sucking, if you look on-line, there is a homeopathic liquid you can buy that you 'paint' on the offending finger before bed - it makes the finger/thumb whatever taste bitter, totally safe for the kiddo though. I'll try to see if I can hunt it down for you. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Spang Underground