Spang Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Spang bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for rent in Spang courtesy of Military Real Estate!

How do you feel about the mandatory flu vaccine?

who's talking here?

RoxAnne 1
Rachel 5
Renee 4
Kristen 4
ChristinaM 1
jacinta 1
J3nnif3r 1
badstreetusa 1
Jason 3
Kristie 1
Spangalang 1
lagjeg 2
kari 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Renee --- 16 years ago -

How do you feel about the fact that DoDDs students must have proof of a flu vaccine by November 29th, or they will be disenrolled from school? We have never done flu vaccines and I wasn't planning to this year either but... You can get a waiver for medical, religious or personal reasons, but it seems as if it would be a hassle. So flu vaccine here we come! Also, just wondering if I'm the only one who didn't know about this until today? 

Rachel --- 16 years ago -

I heard about it a little while ago. I would get the waiver. I know several families in the states who do that for various vaccines, and it's not a big deal. I think mandatory flu shots is going overboard. Healthy people don't die form the flu, not even H1N1. If you are not an infant, not elderly, and have no respiratory or immune system issues, I don't believe you NEED a flu vaccine.
Actually it is just a form that you sign and turn in, saying you understand that if there is an "outbreak," your unvaccinated child cannot attend school. Whatev. 

badstreetusa --- 16 years ago -

I'm for the vaccine. What's funny is that a lot of people don't get it (adults and children) but then raise holy hell when they get sick...get the shot or mist and move on...there are exceptions...allergies, etc. 

kari --- 16 years ago -

Meh, the only time my husband or I have ever gotten the flu was right after getting the vaccine, so my son won't be getting it either. If he were in school I'd get the waiver! 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

when our kiddo starts going to PS he will get the waiver......if they send him home woohoo vacation, I am all about vacations 

Jason --- 16 years ago -

Hahaha healthy people don't die from the flu. That's really good!

The number one cause of death in the civil war was disease. Soldiers from different areas were suddenly exposed to new diseases. The military now gives every recruit entering 'bootcamp' a flu vaccine. They save lives by helping to get the immune system ready.

I think a reasonable amount of thought went in to the decision to require the students to have the vaccine. There are many factors which were likely to be taken in to consideration, including the desire to stop the spread of influenza.

If you don't think influenza is such a big deal read about the pandemic in 1918. People with the strongest immune systems died when their immune systems overreacted to the virus. 1/3 of the people in the world got the flu, 10% of those who got it died. 50 million people died! In the winter it was so cold in ny city and there were so many dead they had to burn the bodies in piles. 

lagjeg --- 16 years ago -

This is the first year I have given my kids the flu shots since they were babies. Last year when the N1H1 vaccine was available I was very hesitent about getting that for them as well, and I ended up opting out of it. However, this year my opinion has changed.

As mentioned above, healthy people don't die from the flu... or h1n1... thats wrong. Anyone can die from it.

I wish I could find the link to share about a healthy mother of a toddler who got the swine flu last year. She is a friend of the family. She was healthy and never had any medical problems. when she got it last year she nearly died. She was in the hospital for 4 months from it. Before she was released in March 2010 she had to learn how to eat and talk again. She is still going to physical therapy to learn her speech and simple tasks. Maybe she didn't die from it, but her life will never be the same.

Here in Minot, Nd there was the swine flu outbreak. While no one died, alot of kids were sick for several weeks. I would rather my child not go through that then listen to her whine about getting the shot or a mist.

So, yes, my opinion about vaccinations have changed. My daughter was able to receive the flu and h1n1 a few weeks ago at school. I am waiting for them to have enough for my other child who is 3. Right now its only available to active duty. 

kari --- 16 years ago -

Hahaha healthy people don't die from the flu. That's really good!
No need to be condescending.
I think I'll stop driving, or putting my son in a car. 37,261 people died in car crashes in the US in 2008.
The flu does kill people, as do numerous other sicknesses and outside hazards, but I believe the question was asked to start a healthy discussion, not to invite indirect insults. 

lagjeg --- 16 years ago -

I wonder why its mandatory at a DoDD school and not at the schools state side? Its not mandatory here at least... just at the CDC and home day cares. 

Jason --- 16 years ago -

Kari I wasn't trying to insult Rachel. Rachel if you felt I was insulting you I'm sorry, it wasn't my intention. I just found extreme humor in the statement. It was like saying 'cars that are working well don't break down'. Of course not, once it breaks down it's no longer working well. If you get the flu you are no longer healthy, so of course healthy people don't die from the flu, sick people die from the flu.

I'm wondering why so many people are afraid of flu vaccines. Is there some concern that they are not healthy or something? 

Kristie --- 16 years ago -

We all got ours. I wasn't happy that the H1N1 was with the regular flu shot but I figured it was best to get it anyways. My step-daughter got hers. she doesn't need to miss school, she has enough trouble keeping up as it is. 

Rachel --- 16 years ago -

Uh, I was talking about in modern times...using statistics from 1918 is not relevant. Hilarious.

You can check the CDC (Center for Disease Control) or WHO (world Health Organization) online to see exact numbers of how many people die from the flu every year, including H1N1. You don't have to guess, the info is really there :) If you want to be technical about it, usually NO ONE, even immmuno-compromised ppl are actually dying of the flu; it is a contributing factor to their other illnesses/conditions, and those are what they die of.

I am not anti-vaccine by any means; I just don't think the flu is serious enough to be a required vaccine. I'm glad is it available for those who need or want it. And if you don't think the flu is so serious either, but you want to get the vaccine to avoid being yucky sick for a week or two, that's fine too. I'm not saying anything bad about it, just my opinion on it being mandatory, which was the original question.

P.S. The overuse of aspirin as treatment was a major contributing factor to the huge amount of deaths during the 1918 pandemic; again, not the actual flu itself, but our human error in treating it.
And from 1900-1933, heart disease and cancer deaths still vastly outnumbered flu deaths, yet McDonalds is still open, soda is for sale, and you can smoke and drink all ya want. Where is the french fry vaccine??!! 

kari --- 16 years ago -

The overuse of vaccines in general is not healthy. There was a lot of debate about what was contained in different vaccines, including mercury and formaldehyde, which was being pumped into very young children. People speculate about autism, ect. when it comes to that. I believe there is no longer mercury at least, but giving a lot of shots all at once can overload an immune system. Vaccines are important, but the fewer the better and they should be given to a healthy (no snifflies) child who's body is prepared to work efficiently with the shot. If they are very healthy and things like a bout of the flu and chickenpox don't bother parents, then picking and choosing vaccines should at least be an option. Living here overseas though we naturally have less options in the cocoon of the base, that is something some parents (myself included) really take a stand against. 

Rachel --- 16 years ago -

Yes, you can't take your little ones to the CDC if you do not vaccinate fully, including the new flu requirement. No waiver for that place, so that kinda sucks :( 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

chickenpox vaccine doesn't work anyhow.......just sayin' 

J3nnif3r --- 16 years ago -

NORMALLY, I wouldn't vaccinate simply because someone/something affiliated with the military says it's mandatory (I tend to hate military medicine...) BUT, I chose to vaccinate my 8 and 3 yr olds this year because we had a new baby coming into the house... and anything I can do to prevent the baby from getting sick, I'm gonna do :) (PS - they were vaccinated prior to her birth) just in case anyone thought I was crazy for injecting them with the flu to come home and be around her. 

Rachel --- 16 years ago -

Well either does the flu vaccine, necessarily. It is made from the most prevalent flu strains of the previous year, but new ones crop up constantly. So no flu vaccine will ever immunize a person against the flu; it can only decrease your chances of getting it. 

Rachel --- 16 years ago -

Yeah, the only time the kids and I got the flu vac was when mine were infants and I was still working around children. I was kinda bullied and pressured into it, but whatever. I don't see myself getting it again anytime soon. 

Renee --- 16 years ago -

That is one of the reasons I don't really see the point in it Rachel. The flu virus changes so rapidly that it can mutate and re-infect all within a week in a single family. The vaccine cannot keep that from happening, can't keep us from getting sick, it only helps us against some strains and only makes them less virulent. So, having it available - great. Making it mandatory seems a bit excessive to me. Regular vaccines have helped eradicate illnesses that were either deadly or debilitating, but the flue vaccine is different altogether and I'm just not sure it isn't doing more harm than good. 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

The way that I feel about it is that I cannot see why it is mandatory. I am glad I don't have to deal with it, at least not yet. The beauty of home schooling. 

Jason --- 16 years ago -

Rachel, the flu vaccine isn't made from the most prevalent form from last year, it's made from the strain they expect to spread this year. This year they made the vaccine from several strains. 

Spangalang --- 16 years ago -

I personally do not vaccinate and have obtained the services of an excellent attorney who specializes in vaccine exemptions. If interested, just PM me. 

Renee --- 16 years ago -

Well, I don't think it will be much of an issue - at least I'm hoping it won't. I'm going to look into getting the waiver on Monday. I'll let you all know how easy/difficult it turns out to be. 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

thank you 

ChristinaM --- 16 years ago -

Renee....I did a post about this when they "mandated" the vaccine. I've never gotten it for my children, and wasn't going to change anything this year either. I emailed the school nurse and got her to email the waiver form to me, filled it out, emailed it back, and it was over with. Good luck :) 

jacinta --- 16 years ago -

So great to see that there are other peeps out there who said "No Thanks!" to the Flu flavored Kool Aid.
I'm no Jenny McCarthy (I'm way hotter ;), Polio outbreaks, healing energy and hairy armpits don't turn me on and I don't think vaccines are the devil.
However, I do think as a society we have gone a little braindead and given the CDC a little too much license.

I went to the school expecting a fight over the exemption but the nurse was very helpful, it took all of 5 minutes. 

Renee --- 16 years ago -

Thanks ladies! That eases my mind. I'll be heading over to see the nurse in the morning. 

RoxAnne --- 16 years ago -

I dont get the flu shot/mist or whatever else there is. I am getting over a cold right now actually. I get sick this time of year every year. I let it run its course and go on with my life. I just watch for a fever. I do wonder though if I will start getting it once I have a kid/s. So when/if that ever happens I will ask on here for advice and we can discuss this again :) lol 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Spang Underground