Spang Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Spang bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for rent in Spang courtesy of Military Real Estate!

Enforcing Rules

who's talking here?

Shanna 1
Rachel 4
Renee 2
C and M 1
Kristen 11
Girl from the south 1
J3nnif3r 15
Jason 1
Kristie 10
rebecca 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

J3nnif3r --- 16 years ago -

Ok... I need advice.

My oldest will be 8 in less than a month. Recently, I've really tried to enforce some standards in the house (that have always been rules) but I've started letting them slide LESS. Here's a few that I'm trying to instill:

A) Put your shoes away in the closet as SOON as you take them off.
B) Make your bed EVERY morning
C) Put EVERYTHING where it goes at the end of the day (before bed)
D) Help take the garbage out

She usually does a good job AS LONG AS WE REMIND HER! But how do we get her to take initiative and do these things on her own??

I started trying to set the example about 2-3 weeks ago... I'm normally the first one up EVERY morning, so I make sure to make my bed, and her little sister's bed (she's 2, incapable of doing it on her own.) I put dishes away from the night before and wash any dishes in the sink... She KNOWS that I like a clean house. This morning, she even asked if she could help with my making my bed, but I politely said no thinking she'd get a hint and go make her own. But no - she left out for school without making her own bed.

I told her for everythin she "forgot" to do, there would be a consequence... so I'm thinking of grounding her from TV (her beloved addiction) until Monday of next week. Perhaps without this distraction, she'll grow bored and focus on the things she's SUPPOSED to be doing!

Am I asking too much of my 8 yr old? Is initiative something that doesn't exist at this age - do I HAVE to remind her all the time? 

Shanna (Mod) --- 16 years ago -

no and yes...

I think chores are great for any child. I have my children do things too. My oldest is 12 and I have to remind her constantly to do things. Little things! If she "forgets" to turn off her nightlight her daddy takes it away. She rememebers next time..lol
When she kept her face shoved in her ipod instead of doing a chore I took the ipod away and she remembered the next time what would happen if she ignored my warning.
When she back talks me or says "NO" I make her go to bed at 8:30. "she hates that!" But she bites that tongue the next time I tell her to do something because she knows that consequences of her actions.

So are you asking to much of her...I say no.
Do you have to remind her...I say yes.

Children are gonna push you as far as they can. That's normal! Unfortunately, we must grin and bear it and remember that it will not last forever. Soon they will be on their own.
I believe it is important to instill in our children all these life lessons so that when they are grown and on their own they are able to function as an independant person. Not someone who requires someone to do everything for them. 

Rachel --- 16 years ago -

I don't think you are asking too much, but I do think the punishment is kinda harsh. Yes, at 8, she should be able to remember to do those things- you aren't asking a ton. But a more effective consequence would be something immediate, yet shorter, just for that day or soon after. Like, if she doesn't make her bed that morning, and put her shoes away, then no TV that day.
A checklist would be a good idea for this age. You can let her make it, you just make sure the necessary items are on it. She can even add others if she wants, things that she always remembers anyway, but it's fun to check them off (get dressed, eat breakfast, kiss mommy and daddy goodbye). Then post it, and help her get in the habit at first of looking at the list and checking the things off in the morning and night. If she looks at it, she will see she forgot to make her bed, so she can do that, then check it off. So she is reminding herself, not you.
Also, there is the whole idea that reward/positive does more than punishment/negative- a special privilege for doing everything without being told, doesn't have to be a "thing". But sometimes I think a consequence is necessary, depends on the kid and the situation. 

J3nnif3r --- 16 years ago -

Rachel - I love what you wrote... why? Because I've already tried it! hehe... We had a checklist for a few weeks, and believe it or not - she'd need a separate checklist to remind herself to LOOK at her checklist. The child is brain damaged, I swear. There's a lot of little nit-picky things that we expect her to remember... like opening her bathroom window after her shower, hanging her housecoat back up... dirty clothes in the laundry... rinsing her dish when she puts it in the sink. We tell her WHY these things are important, and sometimes she does them, other times she doesn't.

I also believe in rewarding positive things. I tell her that the REASON I pay for her to play soccer, and the REASON I fork out money for piano is because she's a good kid who deserves these experiences. Otherwise, she'd be like some other children I know who get to do nothing because their parents don't give a crap.

She's seen the positive rewards of doin what she's supposed to do. ANd believe it or not, if I ground her from TV for not making her bed this morning, she'll simply shrug that off and lay in her bed and play DS until she's allowed to have TV back.

Shanna, I think you're right - I just have to live with the fact that REMINDING her is something I have to do, because she's 8 - and because she's braindead. I just need to suck it up and inhale a bit of patience as I do so :) 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

I agree with it is to remind her as Shanna said, and if you have the checklist like Rachel said, just tell her to go check the checklist--then you don't have to go through that whole list. Remind her once, maybe once am and once pm.

If she is smart, she will go do the stuff RIGHT when you remind her so she doesn't 'forget'.

If she is watching TV in the am, I would say no TV until your chores are done.

The other side of this is that I can rarely get ahem, the adults in this house (as with my teens) to do things without reminders.

I think, even though it sucks, and yes there should be consequence, that you are doing the right thing by leading by example. When an adult doesn't do their chores.........hard to get a kid to. lalalallala not saying what adult in this house leaves their crap everywhere :)0 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

double post 

Kristie --- 16 years ago -

My Stepdaughter just moved in with us 2months ago and she was having problems adjusting to how we do things(she's 9). She's used to being spoiled by her grandparents and not having to do chores but now she has some. We started talking to a counselor at least 1x a week to help her and us get adjusted and figure out how to handle her better. She told my DS that she is part of the family and she needs to act like it. She needs to do her part and not argue or use the excuse "I forgot" since thats her favorite thing to say. We made her a chore chart and it tells her under it what her consequences are if she doesn't do them. We haven't had a problem since with her not doing them. Now the attitude is another thing. 

Renee --- 16 years ago -

I honestly don't remember where I read it, but very recently read an article that was about this subject. It noted that children have both short memories and short attention spans, so it is completely normal and necessary to have to remind them to do things. It improves with age, obviously you can expect more from an 8 year old than a 5 year old, but both still need to be reminded. For me, with my 5 year old, I am content to remind her and have her do what she is told without argument. When she takes the initiative to do something on her own, she is rewarded with warm praise and sometimes something special. For an 8 year old, I would say that you should perhaps choose a few things that are the most important to you. Those are the things you expect her to do without being reminded, and for those there are negative consequences, once she has those down, add a few more. For the rest, just try to be patient and remind her and eventually it will become habit. 

J3nnif3r --- 16 years ago -

"I forgot" or "SORRY!" are the two most frequently used RETARDED things that my child says... in such an overly-dramatic voice that I just wanna slap her until her head spins around! I've told her before that I don't want to hear that $H!T anymore, I just want her to DO what is expected of her.

An example of her thought process... Yesterday, she took her sweet time on her homework. She had a page of math, and a page of reading/grammar... She had from 330-430pm to get this done, as she had soccer from 5-6. She didn't finish her reading/grammar because it involved USING HER BRAIN to come up with sentences... SO she finished after practice. She showed me her homework, and I told her that the last part was wrong (write 3 sentences about a subject.) 2 of her sentences were fragments. So I told her she could leave it if she wanted to get it wrong. She put her homework in her folder and started to put it back in her bag and I said "what are you doing?" She stood there baffled, like - well why can't I just get it wrong?! WTF?! 

Jason --- 16 years ago -

Perhaps the consequences aren't relevent enough to the infraction. She doesn't want to make her bed maybe she doesnt need blankets for a couple nights.

It takes about 40 days for a routine to really sink in. 

J3nnif3r --- 16 years ago -

Thanks Renee... that's pretty darn good advice. I think the BIGGEST is making her bed. I mean seriously - it's like the first thing you do in the morning :P as easy as writing your name at the top of your homework. Oh wait, she can't do that either without being reminded. **sigh** 

J3nnif3r --- 16 years ago -

Believe it or not Jason, I thought about stripping her bed and giving her 1 pillow and a small blanket to sleep with for a couple days. 

Kristie --- 16 years ago -

LOL I know how anoying those 2 phrases are, I hear them at least 20x a day. She loves to run in the house and thats one of our rules to not do, I have to tell her at least 2times a day not to do it. How hard is it to rmember when you are reminded more than once a day for the past 2months. Our stairs like to "trip" you and she loves to run up and down them and she knows she's not supose to. And she will yell accross the house while her brother is asleep and wake him up and all she ever says is "Sorry" or "I forgot" Ugh, it's harder when they aren't yours because I don't feel like I can punish her like I would my own child. 

Renee --- 16 years ago -

LOL! My husband had a similar situation with our daughter not long ago. She was having a cow over cleaning her playroom. He said, "Fine, you can either clean your playroom and stop whining, or stand in the corner while I clean it." She chose to stand in the corner and let him do it! Doh! Don't offer alternatives that you aren't willing to, or don't want to follow through on. You gave her the choice, she made her decision. It was an irresponsible decision for sure, but you did put the ball in her court. At that point, you might just discuss the impact of being irresponsible, then add a further consequence. "OK, then, if you choose not to correct what you know is wrong, then when you bring that paper home with a bad grade, you will write 10 sentences for me. You aren't taking away the choice you gave her, but you are adding a consequence for making a bad choice. 

J3nnif3r --- 16 years ago -

Eek, bad situation Kristie. To offer my own advice in your situation - my oldest is my husband's stepdaughter... I would hope that he never felt that he couldn't treat her as one of his own. (different from you though, he's known her since she was 3!)

I think you HAVE to punish her like she's your own, or she's always going to have it in the back of her mind that you treat her differently, or she has an advantage because she isn't yours, etc... make sense? 

Kristie --- 16 years ago -

She has to spend the day in her room this afternoon because she gave her dad attitude this morning when he told her she needed to wear jeans and not leggings and she says "whatever" to everything. She went upstairs screaming and throwing things and now she gets to spend the rest of the day doing nothing in her room. She gets to come eat and do chores and got get her shot and thats it. 

Kristie --- 16 years ago -

But, I don't spank and I don't really know how to punish a 9yr old except taking things away. It's hard to do that because she doesn't get to use electronics on school days so we can only take away her weekend things. If something happens on Monday what am I supose to do then? Making her stay in her room is the only thing she doesn't like so thats what we do. 

J3nnif3r --- 16 years ago -

We don't spank either... Well, the 2 yr old gets a little swat when it's warranted, but there are other effective means of punishment in this place.

Stevie doesn't respond to having things taken away, because she knows she'll get it back eventually. She simply finds something to fill the void until it comes back. (which pisses me off!) haha

She HATES chores. The other day, when she just couldn't get along with her sister to save her life - I made her sort and put away all the clothes... You'd think I asked her to scrub the toilet with her tongue :P 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

[i]"SORRY!"[/i]

aah yes the ssaaaaaaarrrreeeeeeee, sigh, stomp

I agree with Jennifer also, our foster kids said that was the one thing that they loved, is that we were treated just like everyone else.

The first time I grounded our oldest guy he smiled. I was so darned mad at him, I could not find him after school, long story, but he was glad that I had been worried, I was crying. He was so happy to be grounded over it. He was not 9 though, he was 16 then.

Basically, it is hard to fit in at first, just remind her that it is cuz you love her. Maybe go in and chit chat with her while she is grounded. Get to know her. Grounded to her room=captive audience! 

Kristie --- 16 years ago -

LOL, Alexis has 3 chores a day to do and if we ask her to do anything else she argues that it's not her chore. It's kinda funny to see her and her dad handle it, they are so much alike. They are both hardheaded and has to have the last word. It's funny how she can be so much like him and never lived with him.
Alexis doesn't really do much besides read and play with her brothers toys, thats why she goes to her room as a punishment. When that stops working I don't know what we will do.
She's no longer aloud to keep her books in her room since she wont go to sleep at night. Her dad will tell her she has 20minutes to read then go up there to turn her light off and as soon as we go to bed her light comes back on and she reads until God knows when. So, I told her we could take her lightbulb and nightlight or her books out of her room and she chose books. 

Rachel --- 16 years ago -

It's gotta be hard for her, so much change. Now she's not the center of attention any more. It's cool that she doesn't get to do a bunch of electronics during the week, I think, even though it limits how you can punish her. Sounds like going to her room is good, though, cuz she probably loves being around you guys. That way she doesn't get to.
Another thing you can try is having more things for her to look forward to, so there is something else to take away. Okay, it sounds kinda evil when I say it like that, but I mean, we're gonna go for a walk later, or get a scoop of ice cream, or whatever she likes, but only if you follow all the rules, etc. Most kids that age just like to go anywhere. Then, remind her about it, but if she doesn't follow through, she doesn't go. I hate taking stuff like that away from my son, but if he never experiences the consequence, the threat holds no meaning.
Plus, I like to just surprise him with things when he's been extra great- Wow! You ate all your food with no fussing, and cleaned up your toys, and were nice to your sister. You had a great day! Let's go outside and ride your bike! So he didn't just behave to get the reward; he didn't even know about it. Then I make a big deal about how proud I am of him. For him right now, making me happy is high on his list (he's three). 

Rachel --- 16 years ago -

Jen, I've had a couple of friends in a similar situation as you, with taking away one thing, but they don't care because they have others. They both took away all electronics at once as a punishment- go to your room and no TV, no video games, no computer. One friend called it "no screens." 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

[i]she chose books[/i]

gotta say I love that she loves to read.... 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

[i]One friend called it "no screens." [/i]

yep, that is what we do, we have no screens even when NOT grounded many times.......

it is nice weather out, no need for screens from 3pm till after you are in for the night, and even then ........sometimes reading only 

Kristie --- 16 years ago -

Rachel that would be great if she was a normal kid. She HATES to go anywhere. We went to Ramstein last weekend and she just whinned that she wanted to be at home watching a movie. She even hates going outside. 

Rachel --- 16 years ago -

Ugh. Sounds like it's gonna be tough. Hang in there, you guys will figure it out. 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

well crap, that shoots the idea for playing over here, until it starts getting rainy I guess

but......if she is an introvert, it is pretty common to not want to go many places, count your blessings, at least she wants to read and keeps herself entertained vs. the 'i am so bored' or 'I want to shop and spend all your money' kind of kid....

I know that does not help a ton, but it is one way to look at the up side......

maybe surprise her and take her for an 'online trip' with you to buy some books, or to the library! 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

Jen, let us know what you decide to do, many of our kids are the same age as yours so we should all share/good/bad and result 

J3nnif3r --- 16 years ago -

well I shared everyone's advice with my husband, and we agree with a few techniques... I'm going to suck up in the patience department and revert back to REMINDING her to do things. I mean seriously Jennifer - how big of a deal is it to ask her if she made her bed before she heads out the door to school. I think me being military, I tend to treat her more like a subordinate than a kid sometimes.

AND, I'm going to take the advice of rewarding when she takes initiative. My husband and I agreed that when we have to remind her daily to do things, that it should be considered "the norm" and we all know that NO ONE gets rewarded for doing the norm. But the day she grabs the trash bags off the back porch and hauls them down to the trash house without being asked to - I'm gonna rent out Happyland and the whole town is invited! :P 

Kristie --- 16 years ago -

My SD told us she wanted an allowance so we told her she could earn some money if she did things around the house without us asking her to. Not once has she attempted to do more than what she "has" to do. So she doesn't get it. If you get yours to do extra things let me know how:) 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Spang Underground