I usually don't get a chance to watch Oprah....really don't care for her too much. But she was talking about the movie "Waiting for Superman". I've only heard bits and pieces about it, so I was intrigued. Essentially her topic was the failing schools in America. Keep in mind, I only got to see about 20 minutes of the show. She had several guests who were leaders in public charter schools. These schools do great things for the communities they serve. But some of the means of getting there really got me. Like one school gives their teachers cell phones. They can get calls until 11PM to give assistance on homework.....WHAT?!?! Do teachers not work hard enough in the 10+ hour days as it is? Where do parents fit in to all this? In my experience the majority of successful students have supportive parents. It seems that in these charter schools are successful in part because the parents care enough to put their child in that environment. DoDDS students are successful, not because military children are brainiacs, but because the majority of military parents are involved in their child's education. Of my 7 years teaching experience, only one year was in the true ghetto. I had students who didn't have electricity in their homes. I had students who lived in homes with 3-4 other families. Some of the mothers were prostitutes. I know one father was a known drug dealer. These kids were rough. Regardless, I loved those kids. And I did what I could for them. It was the parents that drove me NUTS. I had a young man that was failing from the get-go. I called his mother to set up a conference. I wanted to help him succeed. She told me that he would never succeed and I needed to shut my white a** up and go to he**. WOW!! Really. She was only one of many. I had only 2-3 students who's parents gave a rip...or even knew who I was. I cut my losses that year and transferred schools. That was not the environment for me. I have friends who can deal with that and super kudos to them. I have a hard time believing that failing schools are a teacher problem (granted many times that's where the crappy teachers end up), a student problem (I whole-heartedly believe that everyone has the ability to learn something), or a government problem (yes, low funding stinks, but that just requires your teachers to be creative and use the skills they learned in college -- I never learned how to use a given curriculum in my ed. classes. We had to make everything on our own. I had to figure out the teacher's manual my first year of teaching!!). I think a lot of responsibility lies on the parents. Yes, some people are down and out. They work LONG hours. They had poor educations themselves. There are a million excuses why you can't somehow be involved in your child's education. To all that I say -- GET OVER IT!!! Find a way. Do your part. Don't expect your child's teacher to be a magician. *end rant*
I agree. I know too many public school teachers and they have it rough. I know that they all say they wish like heck they could have a DoDDs teacher job. Maybe that is why, the parents or something. One plans on trying to get one once her children are grown and out of the house.
I think that our failing school system is tragic. The fact that our own government and school districts have admitted defeat is a huge part of the problem. How are students supposed to be excited about education if the people who pay for it (tax payers, gov, ect) aren't. I don't see this as a failure of teachers but a failure of the community to put more emphasis on a good education.
I think it's important that our country starts spending a lot more on education. Schools need to move to longer school weeks with shorter summer vacations. More programs like woodshop and drama need to be offered.
I watched the entire show and they were not blaming the teachers. But, they were saying that there are bad teachers and principals out there that need to be weeded out. We've all had those teachers that obviously didn't care and just wanted to go in, do their time and get paid. I believe that education works best with good teachers and involved parents.
I believee the failing education system in the U.S. is a combination of all the issues mentioned above plus one key issue no one is talking about. Definitely parent participation is important. Too many parents view school as free daycare instead of a learning environment. I know parents who think that telling their teenager to do their homework, and checking on their grades now and then is being involved. Attitudes like that are one reason kids fail. Underfunded schools and poor curriculum are another reason, and after those, come the bad teachers. However, I truly believe that the number one reason U.S. schools are failing is because of U.S. culture. Americans are selfish, completely caught up in a consumerist ethos that tells them that having stuff, i.e., an expensive car, bigger house, designer clothes and all the latest tech gadgets, is the central concern of their lives. In order to fulfill this, both parents work long hours leaving them exhausted and in consequence, disinterested in their children and community. Until there is a change in this ridiculous value system, schools and communities in America are going to fail while the economy continues to grow and dominate our culture.
I don't really have a way to give much of an opinion since I can only go by what teachers tell me, or what we experienced --but it has been over 4 years since we have dealt with the school system. I am sure things have changed a lot since then. I will be interesting to watch this thread to find out more about what is really going on.
Too many parents view school as free daycare instead of a learning environment. I know parents who think that telling their teenager to do their homework, and checking on their grades now and then is being involved. Attitudes like that are one reason kids fail. EXACTLY!!! The "that's not my job" ideology is killing our students. Kids are the future and if you don't take part in bringing up the future you have no say in what happens tomorrow.
Americans are selfish, completely caught up in a consumerist ethos that tells them that having stuff, i.e., an expensive car, bigger house, designer clothes and all the latest tech gadgets, is the central concern of their lives.
I agree...but not every American is that way. I stay home because I want to be there for our kids. I haven't had that chance until now and I am loving every minute of it!! I would rather be poor and have a wonderful family life, than to be rich and not know my kids! But you are right, Renee. As a whole, our society needs to wake up and realize that "stuff" will get us nowhere but into more debt!! We have to get our priorities straight!!!
They also talked about the teachers unions. How it takes like a act of congress to fire these teachers that are with the union. They had a principal on from a DC school, how she had a teacher who showed up to work whenever she felt like it, and eventually fell asleep in class. When the prinicpal fired her the union said that the punishment was to harsh and suspended her for 10 days. The school eventually fired her. Not all teachers are bad like this one, but there are teachers out there, that don't care and only want the money and be protected by the union.
Renee is right on. All of the other factors don't matter nearly as much as what is happening in the home. Our country had a higher literacy rate and people were generally more informed when we had one room schoolhouses, when most people did not attend more than a few years of school, when families were poor (by today's standards), when the parents themselves were "uneducated", yet much "smarter" than the average American today. Children learned in a real world sense, and they had strong family and community ties. Throwing more money into the school system, lengthening the school day/year, these are all ways to treat the symptoms of a much larger problem. We have done these types of things in increments, and the situation has only gotten worse.
I cannot imagine a longer school day for kids. They already come home with 2-3 hours of homework from what I am told by parents. It should all be able to be done in 5-6 (maybe 7) hours TOTAL including school. When are these kids supposed to play?
Longer school day? They get home at what, 3-330 now? If they have a snack and then do homework for 2 hours, that is 530pm. Rush and eat dinner maybe be finished by 630pm? Next, off to their sport/dance/whatever for 1-2 hours, right? Ok it is 830 now then time to do the rest of the homework then bathe......many kids get to bed I am told around 10 pm? Then they get up at 6am. That is barely 8 hours of sleep. That is not even enough sleep for a child that is active.
Oh yeah, notice, 'playing' is not in there anywhere in that weekday schedule.
So, unless parents are embellishing on the amount of homework in hours their kids have and exaggerating the amount of time it takes to do their sports and other extracurricular activities, I don't know how they can fit more school hours in the day?
Longer school days mean less homework. The reason children are assigned home work is to help the keep thinking about the material longer, this helps solidify neuron connections in the brain making the information more familiar to the student. The problem with summer vacations and winter breaks is that it takes time getting the children back up to speed with the material before they can move on to new material. The same thing is true about weekends, and to some extent short school days. Of course kids should play, but wouldn't it be great if kids could come home from school and play without having to worry about homework?
Jason --- have you ever been trapped in a small confined space -- with 20 germy cranky 5 year olds that want nothing more than to go home and watch Sponge Bob Square Pants -- for 8 hours, 5 days a week?
I LOVE teaching, but by the end of the day I LOVE seeing my students go HOME!!!! And by the end of the school year I am even happier to see them move on to the next grade!
I haven't read this WHOLE post, just the last couple entries...
I personally feel like homework is a GREAT thing. It helps enforce a sense of responsibility in the children - and gets them to realize that learning doesn't JUST happen at school, and it's not just the job of the teacher to help them learn... that sometimes, the learning falls ALL ON THEM!
My daughter is a third grader this year, and she's facing some tough, personal challenges. She's got several things going during the week.... homework, piano, soccer... She's complained that she doesn't have enough time to just sit down and watch TV. (I do have to say that her TV time will pick up next month after soccer and piano are both over for good...)
There's a lot of lessons with homework. Time management, responsibility... prioritizing. I think as long as the teacher knows the amount to assign and doesn't go overboard!
Everyone is telling me 2-3 hours of homework is what their children are doing. That is just a lot.
When I went to school we had a normal school day, some homework but not THAT much. Not even that much in high school. The only time we had that much homework was when we had something big due like a project or a report.
There must not be enough classroom time to let kids work on the assignment in class. I remember completely in grade school even having that option. We had 'study hall' in Jr. High one period. We had it in high school also. There was always time to work on homework in at least a couple of classes.
I know that my teacher friends (3 of the 4 have been teaching over 15 years, one over 20) have said that the state testing is a priority now. There are many hours spent on that that used to be used on regular lessons.
One of my BFF's is a teacher, she was MY teacher for junior and senior year. I graduated in 1984 from what they considered then 4A school district. Not sure how they rate now but it was a good school system. Anyhow, she said the changes now are just crazy, that it makes it hard to be a teacher and actually have students learn what they need to.
It is the responsibility of the child to do homework, but if they choose to do it in the last 15 minutes of class, or at least start it, why are they not doing that now? Is there a 10-15 minute time in class to let the children do the work? I need to check with her as far as how long our classes were then, but, I know our school day was similar in length AND we had some classes every day like gym, choir, and those things that rotate here. We actually had more classes per day, I know that for sure. That must mean the classes were shorter. Our lunch period was at least 30 mins, how long are they now? I am trying to figure out why, if the kids want to, they cannot do some of the homework at school? I think if a child has a choice, they would want to do SOME of it at school and just leave it there then do the rest at home. I think 2-3 hours for grade school and early jr. high is a lot if they are going and doing school activities already all day.
Anyhow, that just is so sad. Kids can learn a lot in a little amount of time.
Practicing over the summer is a good idea, and you are right, if parents don't help their children stay fresh on things like math drills, spelling, reading, etc, over the summer, come the early school year it is hard.
But don't most kids read every night or at least a few nights of the week anyhow?
I agree Kristen! When I was in school we had plenty of time in class to learn the material we were covering, plus some time to at least start on our homework. We also had gym, music and other classes that are being cut out now. I didn't have regular, nightly homework until highschool, and even then we were given some time in class to work on it. I'm not saying kids should never have homework, or that parents should not be responsible for helping their children learn, but kids spend 8 hours a day at school, home time should be home/family time. There are other things to learn outside of academics that parents are trying to instill as well - things that are vital to raising an intelligent, morally and socially responsible person - things that cannot be addressed while the child sits doing homework for two hours, then has to eat and go to bed. In addition, I really believe that having hours of homework every night impresses children with the same kind of "work ethic" that keeps parents at work until all hours trying to bring home that extra dollar to pay for their excess, the same "work ethic" that prizes professional (for children, academic) success over family values.
Right, so, now how can they help the teachers have enough time in class to let the kids do it? What is overburdening them? I know that when the kids we had went to school they were in middle school and high school. I visited the class of our middle school kiddo several times to observe *him* because they wanted him to be medicated. That time was really the only time that I have ever observed what goes on in a classroom these days. All I can go by now is what people or teachers tell me.
I DO think kids should have homework. We had to review our spelling, do multiplication drills, and do a lot of studying. We had tests and quizzes every week from what I recall. I know our son sure does.
I just don't agree with longer school days. I think that would kill the few teachers that are still 'liking' their jobs and push the ones that don't over the edge.
Kristen --- I am curious, how long is your son's school day? Do you have every subject every day? I ask this because my daughter has asked me OFTEN to homeschool her. She is bright and I think I could take her much further than she would go in the classroom. I am BIG on hands-on learning, not so much with paper-pencil. However, she has ADHD and I struggle with getting her to do homework. I am at the point of pulling my hair out an hour into it!!!
Our school day started 1 hour ago. He works from about 8am till about 1-2pm most days. Some days a bit longer. Keep in mind, he CHOOSES to do his homework right after his lesson, so if he did not, we would finish at noon or 1pm probably. He would then have homework later. The only homework he has for later some days is oral multiplication drills(in addition to his speed drills for math that are required daily), spelling drills and daily reading. Most days we do those right during the school day. He takes about 30 mins for lunch. There is not much messing around involved so he is doing easily 4.5-6 hours of school work daily, pretty much non stop.
I don't have to do as much hands on with him as I did K-3 which is nice. It is more of a time commitment now. We cannot leave the house during that time. I miss the every minute one on one sometimes but it is hard on a parent/child relationship, I will be honest. We do about 1/3 one on one now, but it is split up 30 mins here, 10 here, 5 here, 20 there.
We had partially home schooled two of our teen daughters, they went to alternative half day schools. Thankfully we had a taste of what was involved before we did this.
I often wonder how hard it would be to get him to do homework after school, ADHD or not. Kids are ready to be kids by that time of day. Look at this weather, who wants to do homework? His focus all day is 'get it done, then I can go play with the neighbors'. Works for me. There have been days where we have had to split the day up because of an appointment or something and it is really hard to keep that focus going later in the day when he wants to just be a kid.
I remember working with our son that they wanted on meds with his homework. It was hard many days, very hard. I feel ya.
Jason? do they? I don't know. I ask a lot about it though, and I ask teachers who are still working in different states, etc. What is it, besides the state testing stuff that is taking up so much more time? NO more daily gym class, shorter lunches and passing periods in the halls. No more daily music or art. Seems a lot has been cut out?
This is what I get from the teachers I know.......if they were allowed to teach what they needed to and not adhere to the 'state testing first other curriculum later' guidelines, the kids would learn what they needed to for the state testing anyhow in the regular curriculum.
I have to disagree Jason. I actually was learning MORE as a child than what I see kids doing now, and I was learning it sooner; in 4th grade I was learning some of the things kids aren't learning now until 6th or 7th grade. Granted, I was in a very good school system, but still.... Not to mention the fact that, if they are having to send so much homework home every day, it raises the question as to HOW WELL kids are learning. Pushing too much at them at once does nothing but frustrate and confuse, while a reasonable amount helps them master what they are learning rather than just achieving bare proficiency.
I see. Did you have to learn how to use computers as a kid? 50 years ago you would be hard pressed to find physics in school. The level of science and technology we have achieved as a society has forced our children to begin learning how to use their world instead if just playing in it.
yes, we did, and what is funny is that not only did I have computer class but we had typing and office procedures and shorthand! I was not in high school 50 years ago, but thanks for thinking I was :) haha
We were the last class to have keyboarding on a typewriter :o (they got computers after that.) Believe it or not, I never learned to use homerow. Our teacher was a dinosaur, and when I proved to her that I could already outtype every other student using my finger-pecking method, she let me stay with that!
Funny thing is hubby and I were talking since he is the physics guy. They did offer physics when he was in HS. You had to have the prerequisites but you could take it he thinks Jr or Sr year. I know that at our school you could take Chem freshman year if you had qualified and there were tons of other science classes for the other higher years available, I was just not interested.
When I was taking computer class we were writing in DOS, HA. My keyboarding was on an IBM Selectric. Two separate classes
We had to take physics in middle and high school, along with all the other sciences. No big deal. As for the rest of this conversation, kids are learning, or retaining, much less in school today than, say, 50 years ago. Maybe the curriculum looks and sounds very high level, but most of it is not taught in any useful way that students actually understand or retain. The reasons for this are many, but go back to the home. You cannot "teach" higher level thinking and critical thinking skills from a textbook lesson. These abilities develop over time, starting very young, before school age. People acquire these skills from multiple sources in their lives, and school is a very small source. So, if they are not getting stimulation of this sort out of school, and long before they ever enter a classroom, chances are they likely will be deficient in these areas. This is what we are seeing now- a generation of young people who, although educated on paper, have no real abilities, cannot solve problems, and have no motivation, no interest, no sense of purpose or responsibility for their own lives and the world around them. It is getting worse very year.
True, I was talking to someone the other day about how much more time it takes to show our son how to solve his own issue. How to find out about something. How to sort out a problem step by step. How to use your logic, your resources, how to research things. It can be exhausting. That all starts from when they are little and you teach them how to articulate. If they are not taught how to communicate effectively, that can make it hard also.
Teaching good habits, organizational type daily stuff.
As a parent it is just easier to do it for them, but that is not going to help them in the future.
Even though the 'but what if this happened mom instead of this' can get annoying, I am ok with it, it means he is not always just accepting things as they are. He knows that I question things and probably gets it from me, but it does make him THINK.
Kids grow up with no skills when it comes to money for many of the same reasons.
This 'I have to have the new xxx or yyy the day it comes to the store' was a huge topic for our son and I recently. Patience is learned at home. The daydreaming is fine but reeling back in is important. I tend to think that you learn to stay on task from a young age. It is a problem now for kids to 'stay on task' in school. No child is going to stay on task for hours on end (heck, I don't) but a little bit of practice before starting school would probably help.
So yeah, it starts at home, so how does it get fixed? Who is held responsible, and when exactly are they going to stop pushing blame back and forth?
That, I do agree with Jason. I understand the desire to test childrens' proficiency, but "preparing" them for a test that is supposed to be a gauge of their actual ability is ridiculous. By the way, yes, we had computer class when I was a kid, I'm only 35 - and yes, we had advanced sciences, in fact, we were offered advanced sciences beginning in 6th grade. Some of us, also had "specials", which were advanced thinking and problem solving classes, advanced mathmatics and sciences, in addition to our regular classes. Still didn't have homework every night. We did, however, have only one standardized testing segment per year, which typically lasted one week, and we were not coached for it ahead of time.