Myself, along with some other parents, called into the Eifel in the Morning show with DJ Grey. I spoke with Commander Hinote this morning regarding this issue. He was not aware trick or treating was scheduled for the 30th. I brought up the fact that it is tradition that you trick or treat on Halloween. This is the one night a year kids can stay up a bit later. It never killed us. Even trick or treating on a Wednesday. I also brought up an important fact that is being forgotten here: If the base is trick or treating on the 30th that means the folks living in GLH will be hit two nights in a row!! Which, he verified, is an extremely good point. Commander Hinote is checking into the what's and why's of the 30th date and will let us know. Just an FYI!
Pathetic... You guys are so riled up about a one day difference in trick-or-treating... maybe you should join some political protest and REALLY get something done for our nation. :D
Hmmmm. Perhaps you are mad because some people enjoy celebrating a holiday on the day it is supposed to be celebrated? Just because you wanna be cool and show your friends kids around trick or treating doesn't make you any more right. Just as being pregnant doesn't give you any more right to be ugly to people.
ACTUALLY, it doesn't matter to me anymore what night it's on - because our family can stay for Sunday festivities if need be... Nov 1 is a holiday in France after all...
I'm not the ONLY person I know of that things Saturday night is a better idea. And I've been HOPING that nothing changes...
Nov 1st ist a german holiday as well. But you guys sound like little kindergarten kids.....really. Just be nice to each other. I prefer halloween on the 31st, no matter what day of the week that is. But if it would be on the 30th on base, I will not complain, then my kids can go trick or treating twice. More fun for them.
I personally don't care what day it falls on. It's kind of like Thanksgiving, it's the fourth Thursday in November, nobody gets their panties in a twist because one year it is the 26th and the next is the 25th or 27th. They are both just made up holidays anyway, like all the rest, so just go with the floooooow.
Halloween has become too commercialized like many things us Americans tend to change and really is a holiday celebrated on the 31st with religious connotations in some religions and a Harvest festival dating back centuries.
I've never seen Halloween's trick or treating tradition in the USA change the date for convenience of parents so why should it change over here?
Definitely TOO commercialized, Kris. However, being, generally, a celebration of Fall and the harvest, it traditionally changed from year to year based on weather, yearly cyclical events, such as the stages of the moon, hours of sunrise and sunset etc. It was also, at one time, a day set aside to mourn the dead, much like Day of the Dead in Mexico. Many historic events related to our Halloween celebration actually happened on November 1st. The 31st has more to do with the Catholic "All Saints Day" decreed by a Pope of the Catholic church in an attempt to create a Catholic holiday out of pagan ritual in order to assimilate pagan cultures into the church. This is in common with MANY of our observed religious holidays. The 31st is the day AMERICANS decided would be a good day to celebrate this event, which wasn't even considered a "holiday" in the U.S. until the 1900's. It is all subjective. It is simply a day, set aside for kids to dress up, have fun and get some candy. Why does one day ahead or behind make a difference? You'll probably say, "tradition", which is a valid point. But it seems to me that a little convenience, in relation to this particular holiday, is not a bad thing.
PS, going back to the original post, as I have gotten a bit off track here, it seems to me that people would know that ONLY the on-base trick or treating is on the 30th, and GLH, being off-base, would be under the normal "rules" of the 31st.
which gets me back to the good side. Kids get to trick or treat twice. Just more fun for them. Why don“t we add friday the 29th in, maybe somebody wants to do it on a friday rather than that inconvienient saturday or sunday. Just post the adresses, my kids sure would be happy.
That's my complaint- I wish there were some activities on base for Halloween, other than just trick-or-treating. My son is still too young for the candy, but even if he was older, it is just waaay too much candy for one kid :) I miss how there were school carnivals and stuff with games and crafts for the kids to do.
I recall living in England year's ago and the pre-school on base had a carnival type fun day exactly like you described Rachel w/arts and crafts, games, etc. THey don't do this here I guess??
I only mentioned the Harvest/All Saints Day holiday/traditions wondering if the debate over Halloween being celebrated on Sat or Sun had to do with German culture. We weren't here last year and curious if their children dress up like our's do. All Saints Day in Germany is Nov 1 (Monday) so I was even more confused on why Saturday was on the radar here.
We don't have kids at home, but we enjoy handing out treats and seeing the kiddos dressed up in costumes. I can see us going on base for the Trick or Trunking or whatever someone posted about this if it was on Halloween (sunday the 31st). Yes, I'm traditional Renee :-) but open and accepting to other cultures celebrating holidays on other days than we do. Just didn't see anyone suggesting this was the reason other than convenience for parents is all. No big deal to me.
I think that a Fall Festival is a great idea. More fun for the younger kiddos and then it's not all just about candy, and is easier to draw attention to the Fall theme and away from the darker stuff.
Kris, the time of year that they really dress up here is Fasching, it's a lot of fun for all ages. Here's a link to an article if you don't already know about it: Fasching Info Sorry about my earlier post. Iwasn't trying to sound snarky, so I apologize if it came out that way. Trust me, I am quite traditional myself.:)
I have not responded to J'nnifer's attack on my original, and only as informational purposes, post until now. My message was not intended to be an ugly one or start a big ruckus, but apparently you took it that way. If I offended anyone, I apologize. However, J'nnifer, I take offense to your post. We are all entitled to our own opinions, whether pregnant or not. No one has anymore right than any other to be ugly. It is simply a holiday. I called in to the Eifel in the Morning show to voice my opinion, just like anyone else could have.
I wasn't attacking anyone. Simply voicing my opinion, just as you've voiced yours.
I've said it twice... why has NO ONE said anything about the fireworks being on the 3rd of July this year? Just like Halloween - Independence day is ALWAYS on the 4th of July... so why did we celebrate the night before?
Jennifer the 4th of July was on Sunday. Just like we are not supposed to fly our jets on Sunday I assume we aren't supposed to set off explosives on Sunday night.
Nobody is saying you weren't giving an opinion, I just think your opinion was rude and stated in a way that was clearly designed to belittle others for having their own opinions contrary to yours.