Spang Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Spang bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for rent in Spang courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Military Bans "Medal Of Honor" Game

who's talking here?

Summer 4
Christina 1
Aaron 3
J3nnif3r 1
Jason 4

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Aaron --- 16 years ago -

undefined

What's you take on the ban?
What's your take on the game? 

Jason --- 16 years ago -

I can understand the sensitivity to the issue. More importantly you have people coming back who saw their buddies killed. The game is known for the lifelike violence and it seems reasonable to believe this product will not benefit the mental health of soldiers returning from combat. It is likely this product could have a negative effect.

Of course the military isn't saying you can't own it, just that they don't want their stores selling something with the potential to cause those problems.

I think it's a smart idea. 

Aaron --- 16 years ago -

@Jason: I think it's smart move from AAFES too. I think Electronic Arts knew that this would ruffle some feathers when they made it. It takes a mediocre release (from what I could tell) and made it into a controversial sales ploy. Cheap if you ask me. 

Jason --- 16 years ago -

I bet it's a pretty cool game, but not meant for some people. 

Summer --- 16 years ago -

I think that the ban is BS. First of all the only way that you play as someone trying to kill American soldier is if you are playing against someone else....there has to be a bad guy if you are playing PvP. Otherwise it would be US soldiers vs US soldier.

Secondly, more my objection comes from the implied censoring of content at the BX. This is just the first rock in a potent landslide. Soon we will not be able to buy movies in which the US government is the culprit...

Thirdly, this is an example of the short memory of the American people. There are multiple games on the market and available through the BX that allow the player to play as a Nazi or Axis soldier during WWII. No one is up in arms about this....

Overall I think that the ban was a knee jerk reaction by a bunch of jackasses in suit who have no idea how to turn on a game system. Frankly I am disappointed in the BX. THough that is nothing new! 

Jason --- 16 years ago -

I'm sure you'd be a little more sensitive to the issue if your buddy starts having a violent anxiety attack triggered by the game you are playing. They aren't saying you can't buy it, they just aren't selling it. 

Summer --- 16 years ago -

Not selling it is not going to stop anyone from buying it and so that same buddy would be equally affected either way.
I personally think that all these games are stupid wastes of time, but I don't like the idea of the BX banning stuff. 

Christina --- 16 years ago -

So AAFES is not going to sell this because of PTSD issues? 

Aaron --- 16 years ago -

No, AAFES has taken the stance that since US Military members can be killed by Taliban insurgents in the game and the player can act as the terrorists, then they will not support it.
I think that since their clientele consists of military members, it's a good call on their part. They are not telling you that you can't buy it--it's not a base-wide ban. They are simply saying that they will not be the one to sell it to you.
This is not a case of "the man gettin' you down." This is a case of a business protecting their own interests (which they are legally allowed to do).
They simply will not assist you in slaughtering US troops in a virtual setting. The fact that anyone would want to seems a little warped to me anyways. 

Summer --- 16 years ago -

The game play only includes that option when you are doing player vs player. Would you rather US soldiers were killing US soldiers?

Additionally the BX sell another game in which you can play as a Nazi and shoot US troops....why is that one okay?

I agree that wanting to pretend to shoot your fellow soldiers is a bit morally off but I do not think that it is a good precident for the BX to set. 

Jason --- 16 years ago -

I'm sure if we were at war with Nazis they would make sure not to sell it. 

Summer --- 16 years ago -

Who we are at war with is not the issue.

The issue is the emotional affect of games that show the shooting of US soldiers. This is shown in Nazi, Vietnam, and Gulf war games. How do you think these games make veterans feel? AAFES doesn't seem to care about that. 

J3nnif3r --- 16 years ago -

Does it really matter? Why do people REALLY care? If veterans were really affected, they'd protest the root of the game (the makers) not the people who sell them... Cause so what if you can't get it at a discounted price at the BX... if the person who was going to buy it at the BX couldn't get it there, they'd either download a version online, or get it off base. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Spang Underground