Spang Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Spang bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for rent in Spang courtesy of Military Real Estate!

A $50 question

who's talking here?

RoxAnne 2
Rachel 1
Kristen 5
Summer 2
Jason 1
chang! 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

If you knew that someone was *truly* not spending on non-necessities in any areas of their life, and they needed just an extra $50 of income a month to get by for real necessities, would you give up something you usually used that $50 for to give it to them? YOU WOULD HAVE TO GIVE UP something you normally spend the $50 on, this is not just $50 that you normally have laying around as extra money

*edited to add--this came to mind while doing my sociology homework and this is why I am asking* 

Jason --- 16 years ago -

Sure.

Would you go a day without food so that someone could eat for a day? 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

absolutely...........I should more often then maybe I could fit into my jeans better.......

What would you give up that you normally spend the $50 on that you could do without? 

Summer --- 16 years ago -

I think that I would be willing to help someone out in this way if they were close to me (friend or family) and if I saw that they were trying to get into a better situation. Or if it was someone I encountered that was really trying to make a beter life for themselves and just needed a break. If they were just happy to cruise along, struggling to make ends meet and collecting my "charity", then no I would not give them the cash. Not to sound heartless but that is how I see it.
I would give up my more indulgent food items; good olive oil, fancy dark chocolate. I really don't think that I spend 50 dollars a month on excess stuff though. We save, so I guess that is what I would give up. I would give 50 dollars that would have gone into savings. 

Rachel --- 16 years ago -

I would give up eating out a few times, and fancy coffee :) 

RoxAnne --- 16 years ago -

hmm...I agree with Summer. I am the type that will give you the clothes I am wearing if you NEED them.

Not sure what I would really give up though... 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

what would you give up if you did not have $50 extra to spend though, if that $50 was really part of your money to just make ends meet? or would you not do it? 

RoxAnne --- 16 years ago -

what would you give up if you did not have $50 extra to spend though

This is hard to answer...b/c I would give up internet or cable or something BUT if I didnt have an extra $50 to give up then I wouldnt have either of those things...let me think back to when we were dirt poor and had none of those things...hmm...

I guess the only thing to give up would be groceries or electricity....not giving up electricity...not sure I would feed another family before my own. This is a hard question... 

Summer --- 16 years ago -

Kristen- IF I needed that money to make ends meet in my own home, then no I would not give it to someone else. It may sound selfish but I think my family comes first. If I was so scrapped for cash that 50 bucks would make that much of a difference then I am not gonna be handing it out. Even if I didn't spend it on neccesities I would put it away in case of emergency. IF I had family in that situation that they needed the extra money and I was so broke, I would find other ways to help. Free babysitting, shared meals, some gas, but not a hand out when my family is struggling. 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

Thank you all for replying. I like my classes and it is interesting sometimes to other people's take on things. 

chang! --- 16 years ago -

First off, if my family was already struggling then I don't believe that I would take from them to give to someone else. Like Summer stated, I would try to help the family in non-monetary ways.
BUT, every situation is different. So, I would look at the other persons situation. Do they have a second or third job to make ends meet? Are there children involved? Do they consider "necessities" things like cell phones (high end ones), fancy cars, more than just basic cable, or do they get their hair and nails done regularly?
If I did decide to do it this I would probably take the money from our food budget. We don't eat out much, but we can cut down on the amount we spend on food.
Have fun in class! I'm taking a socy class this term also. 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

oh chang! we have to discuss all this fun Soc stuff then!

I like reading the responses because so many of the stats amaze me and provoke questions. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Spang Underground