Spang Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Spang bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for rent in Spang courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Another good debate...

who's talking here?

Renee 7
mckenzie 1
Kristen 2
J3nnif3r 7
Rachelle 2
megan 1
Jason 1
Kristie 3
ZebraInspired 1
Amy 2
June 3

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

J3nnif3r --- 16 years ago -

So - would you speak up?

I was in the commissary the other day, and there was a mother in there with her three boys. One was in the stroller, and two were being typical boys (didn't really look like they were misbehaving, just a little hyper... at least they were WITH her and not running all over the store.) Anyway, the mother appeared to be the type who was determined to argue with them about everything. She kept saying "No this, and don't that" and she finally got fed up and smacked the one child in the back of the head. It wasn't a love tap either, but rather a pretty hard slap.

I know the one lady made headlines recently for smacking her 13 month old in the face and on the legs on an airplane...

Would you speak up if you saw it?

I personally had already made my mind up that if it happened a second time, I'd say something to her... but it didn't in my presence. I understand hyper children, mine aren't perfect... but I just felt that slapping a kid in the back of the head doesn't TEACH anything, and only demoralizes the situation... Your thoughts? 

mckenzie --- 16 years ago -

i would have said something maybe not directly to her but loud enough for her to here and it does teach them something it teaches them violence and that hitting is ok when it is not. if i had seen it i would have been horified 

Rachelle --- 16 years ago -

I would really want to say something, but any mom who will slap a kid like that, especially in public, probably wouldn't respond well to my concern and just get defensive with me. I just see her then arguing with me over minding my own business, etc. 

J3nnif3r --- 16 years ago -

I live on the 3rd floor of base housing, and heard my first floor neighbor spanking their son in the basement bedroom from my bathroom window... it went on and on and on until finally I'd had enough and I went down there and confronted him. I did contact family advocacy the next day, because they denied doing what I HEARD them do, until after about 5 minutes of my own interrogation they admitted to it.

Anyway... there's a right/wrong way to spank (in my honest opinion.) You slap a 16 yr old in the mouth when their pants have gotten too big for them. (ie, they cuss you out, etc.) I give my defiant 2.5 yr old a good swat on the butt for telling me NO! if I ask her to pick up her mess in the living room... but repetitive hitting that lasts for over 3 minutes is TOO much... and random acts of hitting in the middle of the commissary isn't acceptable either.

PLUS - she was blocking the Little Debbies. I'm pregnant... That didn't win her any points with me either. 

Rachelle --- 16 years ago -

Yea, it makes you think ... If she's slapping her kid in public, what is she doing in private?!? Scary. 

Jason --- 16 years ago -

I'm a big fan of freedom when raising children. Try having a rational argument with a 5 year old and see how far you get. Sometimes you might get them to understand but other times kids will have an absolute disregard for your authority. (of course not your kids, they're angels). There is a serious lack of discipline in many children these days and a great deal of it comes from the fact that children often have no consequences for their actions. I mean what can you really do? Take away dinner? That's starving a kid. Don't let them leave the house? So what. Make them sleep in the cold? No chance.

As adults we have real consequences for our actions, but children don't. I'm a firm believer that stupid should hurt, especially when the brain is trying to form ideas about cause and effect.

Now I'm not saying you should cause permanent physical injury, but if nothing else is gonna work what is wrong with physical punishment?

As far as someone taking my kid away..... Over my dead body. 

ZebraInspired --- 16 years ago -

Omg yesturday I was at the playground and a mother showed up with like 5 kids. She kept yelling at her kids who weren't do anything. And then she proceed to say if u don't stop I am gunna beat the shit out of your bottom. Excuse me my kids are young and your talking like that. Then her daughter was in front of her and yes she kept calling her daughter to come to her about 4 times then she decided to yank the crap out of the little girls hair. The little look very young. My jaw dropped cuz she actually pulled hair out. I was so close to go up to her and pull her hair and show her that doing that to a child hurts more than doing it to a adult. But my daughter was around so I just kept staring at the lady gunna see if she was gunna open her mouth to me for looking at her. Cuz if she would I would open a can of whoop butt on her! Then this lady continue to tell her kids get off of me your gunna ruin my gucci jeans n gucci shoes. Excuse me u got kids n ur going to the playground don't dress as though ur going to a club! Sorry last part I had to vent! 

J3nnif3r --- 16 years ago -

I'm always disappointed in mothers who just can't talk to their children. Like the lady I saw at the post office who had a 3 or 4 yr old daughter who wanted nothing more than to take a look at a magazine... she turned around and snapped at her and said "IT's MINE!" I was like wow, who is the toddler in THIS scenario?!

I realize that other peoples kids aren't perfect. EVERY child goes through phases and stages in life and holy crap I'll be the first to admit that mine would drive me to severe alcoholism if I wasn't pregnant and couldn't drink lol.

But it's like I told my husband last night - we didn't have kids JUST to carry on our name... so what are we doing if we can't have fun with them, spend time with them, and enjoy them for the SHORT time they're under our roof? 

Renee --- 16 years ago -

I have mixed feelings about this. I am definitely in favor of corporal punishment, but at the right time and in the right place. I generally save spanking until we get home - my daughter is EXTREMELY willful and definitely needs her butt spanked on a regular basis, but it's her butt and it is controlled to a predetermined number of swats. She will occasionally get a quick swat in public to get her attention, a couple of times I've grabbed her ponytail, but never really pulled her hair, just held it firmly, again to get her attention. If someone then came up to me and confronted me about it, I'd have to admit, I'd be a bit annoyed. A smack in the back of the head is different, then say, a smack in the face, but it also depends on the age too. Like you said J'nnifer, a 16 year old, yes, a toddler, no way. It isn't necessarily a horrible thing, but it does show a lack of self control on the parents' part, which then doesn't set a good example for the kids. I'm rambling - sorry. I recently went through several months of serious health issues and was often in severe pain while doing things like grocery shopping etc. I have to admit that my temper with my girls was short and I often either overreacted, or would just ignore things because I didn't have the energy to deal with it. (I'm paying for my lack of consistency now and having to undo a lot!) I'm sure people probably looked at me and may have wanted to comment on my parenting, but they didn't know the whole story, nor if what they were seeing was a normal thing or just a really bad day. I tend to give people the benefit of the doubt, because I hope they would do the same for me. If I saw blatant abusive behavior in public I would certainly say something, but anything in a gray area, I think I would stear clear. 

J3nnif3r --- 16 years ago -

Good points Renee... On one of my bad days I probably would have asked the lady to do the same to my kids (cause I wouldn't do it myself) haha...

I guess being military, I kind of let a certain "motto" (for lack of another word) drift over into my parenting... "Praise in public, punish in private." Maybe we'd ALL be happier people if the problems stayed in your personal arena. Don't bring your crap to the commissary to ruin my day.

I DIDN'T GET MY BROWNIES! 

Renee --- 16 years ago -

Sorry you didn't get your brownies Jen! LOL! I tend to agree with your "motto" for the most part, and I think that it sets a much better example in showing restraint and good judgement to your children. At the same time, I like what Jason said too, "stupid should hurt". There defintiely has to be consequences. It would sure be nice if we could keep our problems in our "personal arena", but kids being kids, they tend to bring it where they go. And sometimes, problems or not, you just have to get some groceries, ya know? :) 

megan --- 16 years ago -

When i see someone hit their child i give them the stare, and i make sure they see me staring at them. Makes them feel uncomfortable and let them know that what they did was uncalled for. You should try it, especially in restaurants. They try to hide behind their menu's ;) 

Renee --- 16 years ago -

Megan, are you talking about all hitting, ie, hand-smacking, or just inappropriate hitting? I have often smacked my daughter's hand or given her a little pinch at the table to remind her of her manners. You could stare at me all day for that and it wouldn't make me change my mind. I have to say though, "the stare" is one of my husband's favorite tactics to bring attention to the rude or crude behavior of both children and adults! 

June --- 16 years ago -

If you must say something to a parent for what you think they are going to far with as far as disciplining their child, I've read the best thing to do is actually divert attention away from the child. You should try to make some sort of question or comment to distract the parent's focus on the child. If you say something to the parent, you won't get anywhere at all, they'll just become defensive. 

J3nnif3r --- 16 years ago -

I've heard that too, June - and I totally disagree with it. Yeah, it's the nice "calm" approach, but if someone inappropriately hits a child I'm not about to walk up and be like "SO! Did you see the Red Sox game on tv the other night?" I'm either gonna stare at you so hard you're going to feel holes burning in your skin AND you're going to know why... or I'm going to walk up and say "I think what you just did was wrong, and here's why." The end! :) If a parent grows defensive, well I can stand there and take it, or I can simply walk away, but I'll walk away happier knowing that I stood up for someone who can't stand up for themselves.

When I turned in my neighbor, I let them know that if I DID hear it again, I would report them and I wasn't afraid. There was definite anger in their eyes, but they said nothing, they simply nodded in agreement. I let them know that I often hear shouting from their house, that no one seems to use "nice voices" and now that I'm hearing overbearing corporal punishment coming from them that it's borderline abuse. Who knows, maybe some parents just don't realize it because they can't stand on the outside and look in.

If nothing else, offer an alternative to the hitting. There's been a time or two that I'll walk up to a misbehaving child in a store and simply say "I bet your mom or dad would REALLY appreciate a little help... grocery shopping is hard!" and they'll settle down! Give the kids a job in the store... Maybe someone can be the grocery list holder, or the one who is in charge of getting a certain item if they can be trusted to walk away for a minute and return. LOOK FOR THE RED CAR!! My daughter is so much calmer if you just plan ahead that you'll just let her drive the stupid little red car cart, even if you're getting one or two things. :P 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

go slap the mom in the back of the head 

Renee --- 16 years ago -

LOL Kristen!

June, that seems like a good tactic. Maybe you could say something like, "Hey did you see that woman hitting her kid over there, that is really inappropriate!" LOL! 

Kristie --- 16 years ago -

Krystal, I definitely would have call the cops on that lady. She would have gotten into so much trouble if she did actually pull hair out of her daughters hair.
And J'nnifer, you could have even called. They have no problem telling a parent that they don't need to slap their child. Of course they can't do too much but the parent will know others wont tolerate it. The SF would actually tell you if what she did was legal. When I was actually working we had a lady slap her 2yr old(?) at the shoppette and we had to make sure she didn't leave base so the SF could talk to her. I would have called, she shouldn't get away with it. 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

Evidently here it is illegal to spank your child if you are German? I asked my landlady about it. She said that you can get in trouble. I guess what I am saying is that I am not voicing my opinion for or against it, but if you are out on the economy, watch it if you spank your child. 

Amy --- 16 years ago -

@ Kristie
I think calling the cops on someone for slapping their child is a little out of line! If my almost 4 year old son is acting up, I'll swat him once on the butt, and if someone called the cops on me for it I'd be furious! As far as calling the cops on someone for disciplining their child...unless the slap was directly in the face or hard enough to leave a bruise/mark, I think calling SF for that is ridiculous! If I want to swat my son on the butt for misbehaving, that should be MY choice! 

Amy --- 16 years ago -

I think it being illegal to spank your child is ridiculous! If they're acting out enough where a good swat on the butt will get their attention, then they obviously deserve it! I DO NOT condone spanking with anything other then your hand however, and I think smacking a child in the head or face is out of line. I don't understand how society expects us to be parents, but when we slap our kids on the rump, they call the police on us! That's half the reason you see so many bratty kids nowadays! 

June --- 16 years ago -

There ARE tactful ways you can handle distracting a mother/father from acting that way with their child. Like "Excuse me, do you know where blah blah is?" It only takes a second to take their mind off of it. 

J3nnif3r --- 16 years ago -

You're absolutely right June... there are tactful ways of "changing the moment's thought process." However, I'd want to be the person that hopefully makes a lasting impression on someone. Sure, she might take 5 seconds out of her frustrated life to tell me where the green beans are - but as soon as I'm gone her focus is going to go right back to her son that she just smacked in the back of the head.

Whereas, if I bring up directly the fact that what I just witnessed was wrong in MY opinion, and tell her why... maybe it will bring it to her attention that she shouldn't be treating her children this way... ever. 

Kristie --- 16 years ago -

The butt is much different than the head. It's padded. 

J3nnif3r --- 16 years ago -

Agreed Kristie. And I can certainly tell the difference as a bystander. If I see a child acting up, and the parent is obviously doing their best to control the situation but a swat on the butt, or even the back/side of the leg is needed - it's cool! Heck, there've been times when I've wanted to swat other peoples kids! (I WOULD NEVER BTW!)

But when you're walking around with your own head in your butt, not really paying attention to what exactly your kids are doing, you just hit them in the back of the head because they're not being perfectly quiet and following you around the store like little ducklings... well... PHOEEY ON YOU! 

Renee --- 16 years ago -

BTW June, I was just joking... I think redirecting the parent's attention can be a good idea. And Amy, I agree wholeheartedly with your comments. Spanking is a necessary tool, and when used properly is effective and NOT abusive. I would be FURIOUS if someone called the SF's on me for spanking my child under appropriate conditions. And Jen, also agreed! 

Renee --- 16 years ago -

Kristen, I have spanked Ella in public here a couple of times. Germans always look a little shocked, but believe it or not, they usually smile and nod in approval if they have seen she had it coming. 

Kristie --- 16 years ago -

I wasn't try to say you should call every time some one spanks a child but I do believe that the butt is the best place. The head is not a good place to hit a child at all. 

Renee --- 16 years ago -

Agreed Kristie. 

June --- 16 years ago -

I know you were joking Renee, it's all good :) 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Spang Underground