Spang Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Spang bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for rent in Spang courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Wikileaks - Another good debate

who's talking here?

Renee 1
MommyBuck 1
WitnessProtectionProgram 2
Jamie 2
Jason 2

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

MommyBuck --- 16 years ago -

http://www.foxnews.com/politics/2010/08/03/congressman-calls-execution-wikileaks-whistleblower/

Just wondering what everyone think of this? I was watching THE VIEW the other day. Like I've said before I enjoy the HOT TOPICS because I like to yell at my tv. LOL Anyhow, they were talking about this and Joy (who I hate) said that she thought this guy, the Army guy should be considered a "hero"! Needless to say, I yelled at my tv. I think I have to agree with the Congressman. If they find these charges to be true I think he should be charged with Treason. 

Jason --- 16 years ago -

I am pretty sure that his actions do not fit the definition of treason. He is not conspiring with a foreign government. 

Jamie --- 16 years ago -

Treason is a betrayal of trust. He has commited treason. Period. Just because he didn't conspire with one particular person or persons, he still put this information out there for anyone to see. He shouldn't have done what he did, it went against everything he swore to do when he joined the military. 

WitnessProtectionProgram --- 16 years ago -

Personally, if he found something to be so morally wrong that he wanted the world to know about it, and he stood up and let the world know about it then good for him.

They are also saying the founder of Wikileaks may have blood on his hands. (Which I call crap, the media has done WORSE damage.) Is he also a traitor? He is an American and knew what this information was about. So should he also be held accountable? Or is he just doing his civic duty? 

Jamie --- 16 years ago -

Ummm I am pretty sure that Wikileaks is based in Sweden and the guy that has been on the news is an Australian, Julian Assange, is their spokeman. So try again. 

Renee --- 16 years ago -

Hmmm...From the things I've read, Bradley Manning, the guy who provided the documents, didn't do so out of some sort of idealistic attempt to right wrongs (he is a homosexual who had just broken up with his boyfriend and was angry at the way homosexuals are treated in the military) he was, rather, a dissatisfied and frustrated guy seeking attention and venting his anger at the military . The things he leaked don't really disclose anything that is out of the ordinary for a wartime situation, however, he did put people in danger as many of the documents he provided have names of Afghans who were assisting the U.S. The potential death toll from that alone (those assisting and all of their family members are now in danger), given the vengeful nature of the Taliban, puts innocent blood on this guys hands. His excuse is that he was trying to expose civilian casualties, but, HELLO, it is a war, people are going to die. And, if you want to be a bleeding heart over civilians dying, then let your heart bleed over the more than 2,000 who have been killed by Taliban roadside bombs vs. the less than 200 that have been killed in error by U.S. military forces. 

Jason --- 16 years ago -

Jamie, your over simplified and vague definition does not jive with the definition used by the united states government. See article 3 section 3 for more insight.

Renee, innocent people die in war it is a tragedy. I agree with you that we have taken more efforts than ever to prevent civilian losses in war. 

WitnessProtectionProgram --- 16 years ago -

Wikileaks has Americans who have helped run the site or get it started at the very least. Even if it isn't based in American does it still have blood on its hands for distributing such information? The answer is NO. Not anymore than what our own media has done.


I've read different stories about why Bradley did what he did. I guess it all depends on whos writing the stories. 

page 1
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Spang Underground