Spang Underground
heart and soul of our community
Login - Create Account - Help
Clean out your garage on Spang bookoo! Or find local garage sales on Yard Sale Search.com
PCSing? Win the lottery? Explore homes for rent in Spang courtesy of Remilitary.com!

Why do people leash their kids?!

who's talking here?

RoxAnne 7
Dawn 1
Shanna 1
Andrea 3
Rachel 2
Renee 2
mckenzie 2
Becca 1
Michelle 1
M'lissa 2
melissaa 1
DeAnna 2
Stacey 6
Sarah 1
WitnessProtectionProgram 4
Jennifer 3
Kristen 8
Jaymee 1
Cathleen 1
Veronica 1
Renae 1
Girl from the south 1
Zandria 1

     » send to friend     » save in my favorites

Stacey --- 16 years ago -

I want to know how people feel about leashing kids: Ok so I was in the bx the other day with my kids and this lady had her kid on a leash. My four year old asked me loudly why he was on it since he is not a dog. If a four year old can come to this conclusion then why can’t adults? Why can’t you just hold their hand? I also have a 5 month old, granted he is not mobile yet, I know I will be able to control both my kids without a leash. If you are a parent who leashes please explain to me why you think you need it. I know some people claim that a kid could slip from your grasp in a crowded area and you could lose them. I have issues with this scenario, first of all if they are fast enough to out run you then they are old enough for you to explain to them why they should hold your hand. If they are too little for them to understand then you could carry them or put them in a stroller, or shopping cart. There are so many options available why do some choose a leash? I should let you know that if you leash your kid most people feel a variety of things when they see you. I get angry when I see someone yanking their kid around on a leash; it really is degrading for your child to be treated like that. I try not to look judgmental, but I probably have a disgusted look on my face whenever I see this going on. Maybe this is rude but it is the way I feel as well as the way most people feel (I think ). If you disagree you are probably the one who can’t control your kid and has them on a leash.  

RoxAnne --- 16 years ago -

Well I disagree and I don't even have kids so who is to say I can't control them? I think they are a great idea. Haven't you ever been to a large store and hear kids parents being paged over the intercom because there kids are lost? I mean even at Wal Mart they are always giving descriptions of kids that are lost.... I do not see a problem with it. Maybe there would be less lost children if more people used them. If I think it is necessary and will make life a little easier when I have kids then you can bet I am going to use them as well! I don't care if people look at me ugly because of it. If it really makes you that angry and see it as that big of a problem then you should call child protective services!!! 

RoxAnne --- 16 years ago -

If it really makes you that angry and see it as that big of a problem then you should call child protective services!!! Just re read my post and realized that looks kind of mean... not meant that way at all. I am just replying to your comment: I get angry when I see someone yanking their kid around on a leash 

mckenzie --- 16 years ago -

i dont agree with them either 

mckenzie --- 16 years ago -

the kids on leashes that is 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

we never had leashes when we were kids.......our parents 1-held our hands 2-put us in a cart 3-had older sibling hold hand I think it is icky 

Andrea --- 16 years ago -

I occasionally use them with my children. Not because I cannot control them, but because I have 3 children ages 5, 3, and 1 so it isn't always as easy as you would think to place them all in 1 shopping cart. Since I only have 2 hands and one of them has to be wrapped around my 1 yr old as I carry him, that only leaves me with 1 free hand. My oldest children aren't always willing to hold each others hands, so to avoid a huge argument between the 2 of them, I choose to use the backpack buddy. (A backpack that my children can carry with an attachment so that I can hold on to them.) I also find that it gives my children a sense of independence and myself a sense of security at the same time. And lets face it, you can warn your children a million times about the danger of wandering off from you in a crowd or a parking lot, but they are still children and they don't always heed our warnings, so I would rather be safe than have something happen to my child and have to live with the fact that there was a step that I could have taken to prevent it and didn't take it. 

Renae --- 16 years ago -

My mother had both me and my sister on leashes (and we both turned out just fine, no broken psyches here) and my grandmother used leashes on most of my aunts and uncles as well. To quote my grandmother "People put leashes on their dogs because they care enough about them to not want to lose them. I care at LEAST that much about my children" I don't have kids either, but do plan on using leashes if they become necessary, sometimes it just isn't feasible to push your child around in a stroller. Leashing children has absolutely NOTHING to do with not being able to control your children. And I'm sorry to say that while you were trying to not sound judgemental you did exactly that, and I'm sure most parents have more things to worry about than how you feel about their parenting skills. 

Rachel --- 16 years ago -

First people on here want to complain about people's kids being "out of control" in the BX, etc., then you complain when some parents choose to use a backpack buddy or whatever to keep better track of them. Parents just can't win, huh? Well, unless they do it JUST like you, that is. I don't use one, but hey, whatever works- I prefer seeing it to seeing a parent yelling at or smacking their kid. 

WitnessProtectionProgram --- 16 years ago -

Rachel, totally agree! If you disagree you are probably the one who can’t control your kid and has them on a leash. Just because one might disagree with you means we use them? Uhhh, nope. I don't use them but I couldn't give a fig if someone does. You never know why someone might use one. Maybe their child has some disorder (ADHD, Autism ect.) and this is the best way that the mom can calmly go to the store. Maybe they are highly used in the area those people are originally from so they see no problem in them. I don't use them because I never even wanted or needed to put my kids in one at any stage in their life but who cares if someone else does. Its the way they are raising their kids and NO HARM is being done. 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

I really never saw anyone use them when I was a child.....so I wonder how parents who had 4-6 kids back then controlled their kids? That is what is kind of interesting--I never used one when we had 3 toddlers but I also had a big cart, the stores had big carts in Alaska! LOL 

Jennifer --- 16 years ago -

I don't use them, but I'm glad the option is there. My children are pretty well behaved, and if they're not, well they ride in the cart or stroller... My youngest is 2 and is learning the importance of hand holding, etc. I don't agree with leashes either, but everyone above has valid arguments for why they might be needed. Every person is different, that's the beauty of the world... sometimes. 

DeAnna --- 16 years ago -

Oh yea I am against leashes. I actually got into a yelling match with a father once over them. I was a nanny of 3 kids and we were in public daily...mall, library, zoo, post office and I controlled them by holding their hands or having them hold my legs. I now constrain myself when I see a leash being used but I may still have the look of horror on my face. I wish they weren't even manufactured. 

Stacey --- 16 years ago -

to roxanne there would be less lost kids if people actually paid attention to their kids instead of getting distracted. Obviously since leashes are legal, child services would have their hands tied. 

Stacey --- 16 years ago -

to andrea ~~~~I also find that it gives my children a sense of independence and myself a sense of security at the same time.~~~ how is this possible? the point of the leash is to get your kids to go where you want them to. I dont think that dogs feel more independent when on a leash so how could a kid? 

Stacey --- 16 years ago -

to renae ~~~People put leashes on their dogs because they care enough about them to not want to lose them.~~~ People put their dogs on leashes because of leash laws or because they have a poorly trained dog who does not listen. I guess people put their kids on leashes for different reasons but the main underlying one is that it gives you CONTROL over where your kid goes. I believe it has everything to do with control. Also i didnt say i wasnt trying to sound judgmental. :) 

Veronica --- 16 years ago -

I don't understand why you would look at someone in horror over a child on a leash or a back pac buddy as some are called. You make it sound like the parents have a shock collar on them. If it does not hurt the kids and they are not screaming in horror or being dragged on the ground, what gives us the right to pass judgment on any parent. 

Stacey --- 16 years ago -

I am pretty sure the last thing a kid with special needs would need in their life is to be put on a leash. But you made a great point (not on purpose) parents do it for themselves, not for their kids. They use it becasue it makes their life easier not becasue it is best for their kid. 

DeAnna --- 16 years ago -

Ahh...but I have seen kids being dragged by them both by parents and older siblings. I don't mean the child was on the ground being dragged. I mean the child was fighting to go one way and the holder of the leash was trying to go another. Man! That sounds just like when I take my very naughty dog for a walk! 

RoxAnne --- 16 years ago -

Well Im glad you are the perfect parent Stacy that magically shops without taking your eyes off your child!? Hmm...im willing to bet that is not the truth!!! Im sure at some point your attention shifts....thats life!!! Its not any better that I see parents caging their kids in carts with NO leg room! Not only that but they pile all sorts of stuff on them? Even when they are in the part to sit they pile stuff all around them! Like I said I will use them If i think they will make things easier for ME!!! Im pretty sure you do plenty to make life easier for yourself too? Those that say your parents managed w/o them so why can't parents now? Well many of our parents might have also went without disposable(sp) diapers!! Etc etc etc so I sure hope your not making your life easier by using those either!!! 

RoxAnne --- 16 years ago -

As for the dragging issue??? Are you serious? Wooden spoons can be used to beat kids so should we outlaw them as well? Everything can be abused if in the right hands! Almost EVERYTIME I go to the store I see a little kid RUNNING holding because their mom or dad whose hand they are holding is walking way too fast!!! Not only that but their arm must get tired holding it up in the air, I have NEVER seen a parent bending down to hold their childs hand so that he/she doesnt have her hand raised the entire time your in the store!! Geez, making your kids arm tired or sore from being raised all the time sure isnt nice!!!! See there are negatives to EVERYTHING!!!! 

Stacey --- 16 years ago -

Thanks, i try. It's not easy though. ;) Disposable diapers? Really? That's not even a comparable example. Yes it makes my life easier but it isn’t humiliating my child in the process. 

RoxAnne --- 16 years ago -

My point is that parents do what is easier for themselves! That is life weather you like it or not! It is only humiliating in some ppls eyes! Every parent probaby does SOMETHING that SOMEONE else finds humliating!! I might find the way someone dresses their child to be humiliating, does that mean they are going to grow up with issues or they have bad parenting skills? Nope!!! It is only my opinion! 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

They use it becasue it makes their life easier not becasue it is best for their kid. I think so too. These things have only been around for recent years........again, what did parents do with 6 kids back in the day? Did the kids run away every chance they got? 

WitnessProtectionProgram --- 16 years ago -

I am pretty sure the last thing a kid with special needs would need in their life is to be put on a leash. But you made a great point (not on purpose) parents do it for themselves, not for their kids. They use it becasue it makes their life easier not becasue it is best for their kid. Let me guess. You must have a special needs child who can't be reasoned with but know exactly how to control them. Awesome! Give me a break, when we put things into abuse categories the child leashes don't even make the list. What's the big deal? Not every parent out there can get control of their kid without bribery, leashes, spankings you name it. Parents do lots of things not everyone would agree with but as long as the child is not being hurt (IE dragged, hit) get over it! And God forbid the day a parent does something to embarrass the child when it may possibly be for the child's own good or even possibly the parents. *gasp* Because we ALL get sick of hearing the kid in the grocery store screaming their heads off in the cart. That ticks me off more than any leashes. That makes me want to tell the parents to take the kid out of the store if they can't handle being in public. But I don't because I've been there (although I always removed them from public when a rare tantrum started) and different parents need different things to cope. I just thank God they found a way to do it without getting that frustration that may push them over the edge and then the child ends up really damaged. Emotionally or physically. 

Becca --- 16 years ago -

Whether you use a leash, a stroller or a cart in the store, they are all devices used to contain your child. If you condemn the use of one well........... 

Michelle --- 16 years ago -

I do not have kids but if I did need one i would use it on them. It does seem like some parents can not win though. if they are running around they get looked at like their bad parents, but if they put them on a leash they get looked at like they are bad parents. I just like seeing parents treat their children like children. Parents get sidetracked, kids run off, in busy areas people like to pick up kids. So the way I look at it is if I was a parent and did get sidtracked, and someone tried to steal my kid in a busy area, well they would find me standing at the end of the leash. I think a parent should be applauded for trying to keep their children safe, no matter how it is done, as long a physical abuse is not involved. 

WitnessProtectionProgram --- 16 years ago -

Whether you use a leash, a stroller or a cart in the store, they are all devices used to contain your child. If you condemn the use of one well........... Quite right! 

Kristen --- 16 years ago -

I don't think it is abuse, I just don't get it. Whatever the parents need to not lose the child, yes, that is good. I don't want a child who is wild plowing me over when I walk down an aisle and if the child needs to be leashed like a wild animal then so be it. I would rather that too I suppose when you look at it that way. I just don't get why they are necessary now and never were before. either way, politics religion parenting three taboo issues I don't think it is abuse though, that would be really degrading children who have truly been abused, they would probably gladly walk around on a leash vs what they have been through. 

RoxAnne --- 16 years ago -

I don't think it is abuse though, that would be really degrading children who have truly been abused, they would probably gladly walk around on a leash vs what they have been through. Very good point! I never thought of it that way... 

page 1 2
Login to add your comments!

see more discussions about...

children
rant

Terms of Service - Privacy Policy - Ice Box

Spang Underground