This article makes it sound like our servicemen and women spend all of their time in the shower. This article plays on a lack of understanding of services provided to many service men. While servicemen can find themselves in positions where they must use community showers many will never have to stand naked with another serviceman after 'bootcamp'. Even the infantry which is the most closely knit organizations have their privacy.
That's just stupid. My husband has worked with several people that were known to be gay and it has never bothered him or seemed to bother others that he works with. I think most people don't care as long as they're doing their job and respect others. Not every gay man wants every straight man.
Okay, so in my old age I have learned that men are easily aroused simply by the sight of a woman partially or completely naked....shoot a woman could be fully clothed and the simple thought of what's underneath her clothing will set some guys off. I am going to assume that homosexual men are pretty much the same. So you are saying that a) my husband should be just okay with being in the locker room after PT with a guy who may be aroused by his simple nakedness when getting ready for work? AND I should be okay with someone lusting after my husband (yes I consider being aroused by the sight lusting)? Jason, I am going to make another assumption that you are married. Would you be okay with your wife showering and dressing in the presence of men?
Like Jason said, it is not like the majority of servicemen and women group shower all that often.
And Gina, it is happening already! The repeal doesn't change that. There are already homosexuals in the military. Your husband has already showered with them. So far, he has survived, right?
Also Gina, as to your second point about being okay with someone lusting after your husband, husbands have to be okay with other men lusting after their wives all the time. I mean, if my husband got angry ever time some dude was "aroused" by looking at me, he would never have a happy moment :) just kidding
I don't know. It just seems to be too much segregation. So, do you have the gay men and gay women shower together? Have four separate shower areas? What about bisexuals?
Honestly, we are just too concerned with our own nakedness and sexuality and too focused on it. I like men, but just the sight of a naked man does not send me into a fit of uncontrollable desire.
Yes, I agree that the average male is more distracted by sex or the idea of sex, but this was the same argument used to keep women out of the military and heck, out of most professional jobs: they would be "too much of a distraction" to the men working there. Sounds like the common problem in both these situations is the heterosexual men. Maybe we need to focus on getting them to control themselves and stop responding to anything remotely sexual like wild animals.
Like Tiffanie said, it would get ridiculous. Just go in there, do your business, wash off your funk, and get out. Stop wondering about who is looking at your oh-so-fabulous body and amazingly huge pecker.
People have been going to gyms for a long time now and showering together with no problems. I never hear of any crazy stories at gyms where gay men openly ogle or attack straight men trying to shower.
Gina, if I had to, and I KNEW nobody was gonna do anything to me.
The whole conversation is tacky. It assumes that gay men are so sexually focused that they cannot be around straight men without doing something inappropriate. It is ridiculous and bigoted.
The men who I usually see using the shower argument are not anybody that ANYONE wants to see in the shower. The irony is hilarious.
And really, to get down to it, Elaine on Seinfeld explained it once kinda like this: the female body is sexually attractive by nature. Meaning, every part of the female body can be erotic, all the curves and soft skin. And usually (except for some clothing styles) it remains covered. So a naked woman, or like you said Gina, the idea, can be highly arousing.
Not so for men. The majority of the male body is commonplace, and we see it all the time. IT doesn't hold the same mystery. Men are shirtless and whatnot regularly. Being naked in the shower, for a man, only reveals two hidden things: a penis and a butt. Not the same as a naked woman. And not to offend anyone, but a penis in a regular, flaccid state, as they usually are in a shower full of ppl, is not very sexually exciting, to ANYONE, gays included. So comparing a naked woman in the shower to a naked man is not an even comparison.
But this kind of logic and honesty does not advance a bigoted argument, so it is usually ignored. The fact is, the ppl who are mad about the repeal are homophobic, but are desperately looking for some kind of pseudo-valid argument to hide behind.
Why is the focus towards showering/nakedness in the first place (I mean media and not SU contributors perse). Several NATO allies serving alongside our American troops seem to operate just fine with openly gay policies. Shoot, Israeli troops are very open and sorry, they are about as bad a$$ as they come.
I do think this is a complex thing though but the first step is to simply allow our military troops who are gay/lesbian to not go against integrity standards and not have to lie. Our soldiers/airmen who are deployed and get injured for example, their partner or loved one are forbidden to be by their side...THAT alone is reason to lift this ban to me.
Like Rachel said, women were forbidden to do certain jobs years ago. Sexual harassment was 'accepted' 20 years ago when I was AD. Give me a break people about the talk about lust and heterosexual men who can't control desires. What about being deployed with women who can't seem to control themselves....married and single...what goes on TDY/deployments between heterosexuals seems more of a distraction towards the mission than this.
If military members have such a problem with their sexual desires or showering with others, then they need to change jobs.
That makes no sense Rachel....I'm sorry. The whole idea behind that is that men are visual creatures by nature so to a gay man the male form is what turns them on just as a female form is what turns on a straight man. That's why Gay men like strip clubs with male dancers just like Straight men like strip clubs with female dancers. From what my husband has told me, he hasn't heard one guy at work voice that he is comfortable with the idea. We are too concerned with being Politically Correct and it's crap. You wouldn't want you daughter going off to college and sharing a coed bathroom without any privacy...showering side by side with men and rightly so. It shouldn't be expected of our men in uniform in order to serve some agenda.
If you think about it - OF COURSE a group of straight men would sit around and complain about it. Any of the straight guys who even THOUGHT about saying that they're "ok" with it in front of a group of complainers would be given the eyebrow like "are YOU gay?"
I too think that people are waaaaay overreacting. I have several gay friends and I love them to death. I don't judge them based on their sexuality.
Just because we find something morally or ethically wrong, does not give us the right to judge someone else. These homosexuals are not asking to impose their beliefs on us... They're simply asking to be accepted and be given the opportunity to be who they are without having to hide.
MommyBuck, most men at work are not gonna say, "Hey, I love the idea of gays serving openly," especially when they are working with crazy homophobes who would assume that meant they were gay. Most servicemen are fine with it, or really don't care. Usually when ppl are apathetic about an issue, they don't say much. It is the ones who are all freaked out that you hear ranting.
Anyway, it's done, so I hope men like your husband aren't dicks about it now.
Wow Rachel...."Men like my husband"?????? Really....... Maybe the men are saying they're okay with the idea of showering with gay men are just trying to appease they're crazy liberal minded wives. Just saying.....I've talked to other wives who have told me the same thing. That their husbands talking to them aren't happy with the idea.....so it isn't just men like "my husband."
Well, yeah, men like your husband, meaning, men who are upset about the repeal of Don't Ask, Don't Tell. Even though they don't like it, I hope they understand the rules and don't harass, exclude, or otherwise mistreat openly gay servicemen and women (you know, the same ppl they have been working with all this time, but now suddenly will have a problem with because of who they like to have sex with).
Why is such a big deal? There are already gay men and women in the military. I haven't ever heard of any straight women or men being sexually assaulted in the shower by gay servicemembers. Why is everyone making it out like these people are predators? My husband isn't comfortable showering with any men, straight or gay, but if the situation arises where he has to, he does it. Simple as that. It's just a shower. If it were my only option, I would shower in a co-ed shower. It's just a shower for pete's sake.
I've talked to other wives who have told me the same thing. That their husbands talking to them aren't happy with the idea.....so it isn't just men like "my husband."
I agree. I am all for Gay marriage and gay people being allowed to openly serve but I think the truth of the matter is there are a lot of men and woman currently serving who are very much against it. Including some very high up important people. This to me means maybe it was rushed and needs more time to work out the details. Which according to what I read will be done.
I may understand wrong, BUT gay people joined by lying and saying they were not gay correct? So then couldn't they just turn around and kick them out for lying to get in? I mean people are always getting kicked out of boot camp for this sort of thing...
I don't think they lied. It was don't ask, don't tell, which means they wouldn't have been asked. And, what does it matter? If someone is willing to put their life at risk to make sure we as a country keep our freedom, who cares what they do in their personal life?
As for the showering, it's a shower! Period. People aren't in there to have a good time, they're in there to clean themselves and get back to work. Just because someone is gay, that doesn't mean they will be attracted to every same sex person they see, the same as us not being attracted to every man we see. Plus, I'm sure that is not what's on their mind when they're at work showering!
Sound the alarm. The gays are coming! The gays are coming! They will brutalize our husbands, accessorize our wives, recruit our children, and finally join into holy matrimony with our four legged friends. Quick everybody grab your bibles, I think I see the Horsemen of the Apocolypse on the horizon...
Hey I just thought of something. The male spouses are always saying there are no male spouses and they feel "alone". MAYBE this will mean more male spouses :)
Jason, I am going to make another assumption that you are married. Would you be okay with your wife showering and dressing in the presence of men?
Gina, my wife isn't comfortable showering around women she's not gonna feel any better about showering with dudes. But to answer the question, yes I would be ok with it.
We aren't talking about high school people this is the united states military. It is comprised of a professional volunteer force. Sometimes people need to be reminded to act like professionals but this is the case with heterosexuals and homosexuals.
The men and women who make up our military volunteered. They asked to serve our country our country didn't ask them. They are compensated well for their efforts and are guaranteed an environment devoid of sexual harassment and sexual discrimination.
There is a chain of command and there are orders. The new order is that openly gay men against. It's not a suggestion. It's not something servicemen get to vote on. It's an order. The professional men and women of the united states military can obey the order or they can find out what their lives will be like with an article 15.
I'm gonna tell you a little secret. The mens locker room isn't a place where hundreds of guys hang out naked talking about how good it is to be straight, it's a room where a bunch of guys change from one set of clothes to another as fast as possible so nobody can see their package. There isn't anything to see. Half the time there is a woman cleaning the locker room. The toilets have walls separating each other, it's not gay heaven, it's a dirty stinky locker room.
This whole discussion is an opportunity for people to apply their prejudices on a group of people. There is an assumption that gay men and women will not be able to act professionally and that they will lose control around all of 'those naked' men. They won't.
You are more than welcome to hate gay people. But now the military has a new policy, they won't ask you if you hate gay people and you can't tell if you hate gay people.
Gays have been serving honorably in the Armed Forces for years.
Gays have showered with you.
Gays have shared sleeping quarters and bathrooms with you.
Gays have given you medical treatment or served you food, or issued you chem gear, etc., etc., etc.
I really don't understand all the freaking out. I have much more respect for anybody that is willing to serve regardless of race, creed, religion or SEXUAL PREFERENCE.
The only difference now will be that Amn, Chief, or Col Smith will be able to publicly acknowledge that they are gay.
The whole issue will be handled just like any other in regards to sexual harrassment, etc. There will no doubt be incidents (regardless of sexual preference) but there will not be complete chaos with gays attacking heterosexuals in mass...some of the comments I've read and heard are dispicable.
The most important thing to remember is that although the bill has passed, the don't ask, don't tell policy is still in place until the new rules take effect.