So we just moved out of a house and on too base (thankgod). Nov 30th we moved out, did the walk through of the house with the landlords and they signed the sheet saying everything is fine. Today we go back to get our security deposit, and they are now trying to charge us 600 euro in "damages" that they supposedly found in the house. This is AFTER the walk through and after the new tennant has already moved in. WTF??? This has me so stressed. We are going to housing with this nonsense next week. Has this ever happened to anyone else? What where the outcomes?? Thanks
We are having the same issues, moved from our house over 3 months ago and the landlady keep half of the deposit because off our damage, we had a housing rep with us when the final out was done, we was told to paint one room and fix the door handle which we did then she come after us with a list of problems saying we broke the hearing system, broke the oven tray etc housing done nothing sent us to legal, they said to go see a Lawyer off base, so we just let her win, it was going to cost far more money to fight her, but now she after us for 1800 euro for water, we have had to find every bill, money we paid her and go back to legal to fight this mess, the housing office didn't help at all. I hope we don't have the same issues with our new landlord when we pcs in a few years, it's caused so much stress and we are still dealing with her, be glad when its finally over
Oh yes, look at an older post about this. Housing is of no help. They even tend to side with the landlords. We went through hell when we moved. What is your landlords name? Or if you want to leave names out what town did you come from?
we came from Binsfeld. The house was in amazing condition when we left. she is tryin to charge us for nonsense things like a dime size rust spot inside the stove, and a spot inside the sink and inside the fridge. things that are used daily and get normal wear and tear. i am sick of getting taken advantage of by the Germans! it is rediculous!!
Did you guys have trouble with your landlords before the security deposit issue? So far our landlords have been great. They live 45 minutes away so we never see them unless we need something. And if we call (even if we say its not a big deal), they are here within 24 hours. Just wondering if your landlords were good, and then all of sudden tried to pull a quick one on you when it was time to leave. I'm sure some of them do it just because they know they can get away with it. Sucks that the housing office doesn't try to help out a little more. Especially if they did a walk through with you and everything was fine!
I am not trying to play devil's advocate here, but Germans in general take really good care of their stuff, like, REALLY GOOD. So what might not seem like much damage to you, just normal wear and tear, would likely be a big deal to them. They buy only a few things, but very nice things. This is why sometimes when we shop off base we think everything is expensive. Germans are more of the mindset that you spend money to buy a few quality items. You take excellent care of those items. Then they lasts forever. Americans are of the mindset to buy the cheapest thing, trash it, who cares, and buy another in a few months. That, and we like to have variety. We are more likely to have 10 pairs of cheap shoes than two really nice pairs (I do it, too, just saying).
So, the same goes for appliances in a German rental house. Again, I am not trying to be jerky, but I am bothered by any "those Germans take advantage of us!" posts. I just don't think it is very accurate.
And stuff like rust in the stove- it's not like that can just be "fixed." The next renter would probably not like that. They would have to replace the stove. It's not really a little thing. Sorry if this post seems rude.
I don't think you sound rude Rachel... I think it's important for other people to understand the German mindset. Not everyone will agree with it, but then again - American renters are renting from Germans so they NEED to understand you know?
But if they signed the sheet, can they still hold back the deposit? I don't know, haven't seen this sheet or been through this yet. What are they signing exactly? If is something saying that everything is in good condition, as you are implying, then they would have to give you back the deposit.
I am not trying to play devil's advocate here, but Germans in general take really good care of their stuff, like, REALLY GOOD. So what might not seem like much damage to you, just normal wear and tear, would likely be a big deal to them. They buy only a few things, but very nice things. This is why sometimes when we shop off base we think everything is expensive. Germans are more of the mindset that you spend money to buy a few quality items. You take excellent care of those items. Then they lasts forever. Americans are of the mindset to buy the cheapest thing, trash it, who cares, and buy another in a few months. That, and we like to have variety. We are more likely to have 10 pairs of cheap shoes than two really nice pairs (I do it, too, just saying).
So, the same goes for appliances in a German rental house. Again, I am not trying to be jerky, but I am bothered by any "those Germans take advantage of us!" posts. I just don't think it is very accurate.
AMEN!!!!!!!!!! I won't even go into what the animals before us did to the house I'm in now...
I don't think you are being rude, you are being honest. Some tenants go in and don't give a damn, and then expect to get their deposit back when they've trashed the place.
American renters are renting from Germans so they NEED to understand you know?
Exactly!!! Too many of us "entitled Americans" walk around like we should be catered to...hello, we're in another country...repect their customs. Don't like it? Don't PCS here or just live on base in a cramped stairwell unit.
Our old landlady was very nice untill we told her we could not afford the up keep off all the bills, nearly 659 euro a month and there is only me and my husband, the house was always cold so once we had our little girl we asked if she could maybe take some bills like water , trash something anyway she said no so we moved to a place that had oil and water included in the rent, she got really pissed off with us and is causing much trouble, we really did look after the house and rented from her for 2 years, we just had to put our child first, we needed her to be warm and nit closed off in one room
My mom has a few houses she rents out in the states. It is amazing what ppl consider wear and tear- like needing to replace all carpeting after a year, broken windows, crazy stuff. I know many people feel like, well, I paid a deposit so whatever, and just completely trash it. Which the deposit cannot cover. We own a house too that is being rented. I am scared to see the inside. If they don't own it, if it is not THEIRS, people act like animals sometimes. Crazy. Look at how ppl treat rental cars or act in hotels. So weird.
I really am not trying to say that all German landlords are great and all American (or British, heehee) renters trash everything. Of course there are going to be some bad apples. It just happens too often that everyone wants to jump on the anti-German bandwagon to excuse their own behavior.
I'm sure you guys did take care of the place, Zoe :) Just not everyone does. Like the ppl that rented this house before us-sick.
Our oil was set at 300 euro, electric 235 euro, water 40 euro each so 80 euro, then bill at end of year, trash 40 euro a year plus 4 euro a month, then we still had our phone and Internet too which was 60- 100 euro a month, so we was always paying out off our own pocket
No offense Zoe Family and I don't want to start anything, but I am just stating the obvious. You know how much your BAH is and how much you can afford to pay for rent and all of the utilities. If you can't afford to live there, you shouldn't have chosen that place to live. There is always base housing or cheaper places to live, you chose to live there and pay out of pocket. I am not excusing the German landlady but you shouldn't have asked her to foot the bill for things that were yours to pay as per the contract you signed. It goes for everything in life....If you can't afford something 1) you shouldn't buy it and 2) you shouldn't rely on others to help you out.
Our oil was set at 300 euro, electric 235 euro, water 40 euro each so 80 euro, then bill at end of year, trash 40 euro a year plus 4 euro a month, then we still had our phone and Internet too which was 60- 100 euro a month, so we was always paying out off our own pocket
Damn that's high...
No offense Zoe Family and I don't want to start anything, but I am just stating the obvious. You know how much your BAH is and how much you can afford to pay for rent and all of the utilities. If you can't afford to live there, you shouldn't have chosen that place to live. There is always base housing or cheaper places to live, you chose to live there and pay out of pocket. I am not excusing the German landlady but you shouldn't have asked her to foot the bill for things that were yours to pay as per the contract you signed. It goes for everything in life....If you can't afford something 1) you shouldn't buy it and 2) you shouldn't rely on others to help you out.
When we moved to germany we couldn't get much info on the cost of oil extra, so most house you can run on your bha, like I say we didn't mind the first 2 years but once we had our child we need my husband pay to go for the family, and why not ask, to get more for your money, lots of houses listed the same as that had something included, hence the fact it's still empty,
I guess we have just had bad luck with the German people trying to screw us over every where we go. I am happy to move on base and not have the worry of it anymore. Our landlords have been great the entire time. We have taken amazing care of the house, and thats why we easily found a new tenant for it in less then 24 hours of posting it for rent. I take very good care of my thingsand I guess you could say Im a little obsessively clean. I know what you are saying by how Americans around here trash things and dont have as much respect, trust me Ive seen how dirty some of my husbands friends houses are. We've also looked at many houses and needless to say most of them were discusting so I dont think all Germans are as anal about their homes as we like to think. At least not the ones they rent out to us. Its clear that our landlords are trying to get money out of us. Things like the stove, sink and fridge are going to have wear on them. Its rediculous to expect them to look the same as they did over a year after they were installed. Give me a break. Thats just not realistic I dont care who you are, German or not. We had done the walk through with the landlords and everything was fine. The other tenant was also moving in that day as well. The landlord signed the housing sheet that everything in the house was fine, but that we would get our security deposit when they recieved the final water and garbage bill. Today we go to get our security deposit and what do you know...She had a whole list printed up of nonsense crap adding up to 600 euro of stuff she found after the walk through and after the new tenant had moved in.
If you have a valid, signed document from the land lord showing where she agreed that you were cleared with no discrepancies, then you've got a case. Good luck.
I was nervous about wear and tear. I asked my landlady to come over once when we scraped the floor once. She said 'that is normal' so I was relieved. I was really worried.
We did do a walk through when we got the house so I imagine that same paperwork is what the exit walk through will be done with.