So I was bored and reading through posts, and wanted to start a little debate of my own. Seems the usual has been discussed, race/religion/politics... What about life?
I have several friends who are seeking fertility treatments of different types because they're simply unable to have children the old fashioned way. I also have known people who had abortions for whatever reason. Where do you stand on all of this?
Maybe I'm biased about fertility treatment because I was able to conceive naturally... but I see how much pain and heartache friends have gone through trying month after month with no success... I can't help but think to myself "Doesn't God play the biggest role in life?" Why do so many people rely on science?
I have many very close friends who have repeatedly lost children or been unable to concieve. I believe that God provided the means to change fertility options, so they should have that chance. I know of so many wonderful parents that had to use less than conventional methods of having them. I am all for it.
I would totally have a baby for someone who couldn't--I loved being pregnant. I feel for those who cannot feel that.
You know Kristen, I often thought I could have a baby for someone else... BUT - I know myself too well... once born, I don't think I'd have the heart to hand it over. I'm selfish in that sense! :)
Well thats only the way to see the one side. Imagine being your friends. Imagine your parents not being able to concieve naturally. Would you have ever wished they would let God take over? If God had no wish for anything but natural conception to take place, do you think it would have?
God gives us free will yet somehow, mankind would love to take that from others and then put it back on what they think is "God's will". Humans muck up a lot of the what bible says or what THEY think God would want for us. Once people realize there is fine line to having your own morals and making others have them too and stop doing the latter, the would will be a better place for it.
As far as abortion goes, unless its medically necessary, I would never choose it for myself. And I can't help but see that women who use it as birth control are doing the wrong thing but not from a religious standpoint. I can see both sides of it but at the same time, I realize that unless Im dealing with my own body, its not my place to judge either.
As far as relying on science, you can't pick and choose. You either rely on God on all stances or science when dealing with the human body. Whats your stance on surgery? What if your life was hanging in the balance? Does that cross over into doing anything to survive or relying on God? Some people will never know until they are at those crossroads and its something we should all remember. You just can't understand something if you've never been there and you will never know what you will choose until you are there.
Great points Cass... I never thought to put into perspective the surgery stuff... but you're right! That's science in a nutshell. I guess I was looking at it from a difference of saving a life, or creating one.
Again, nothing to spark fury, just a good debate :)
I feel very strongly about this since I've had family members tell me that my son shouldn't be here. A child whom they all have enjoyed! He was born at 24 weeks gestation. 1 lb 12 oz. They sat there and said those things when they have never hadd trouble with pregnancies or even been close to making a life or death choice for their own kids. THey also think science is going to far and they think people should rely on God more. But again, they also sat there with all of their opinions after having their lives saved by emergency surgery. Everyone of them.
That discussion with them opened my heart to a lot of things. That unless I became more understanding about a lot of things, I would someday become them. And thats the only firm, non wavering opinion I do have!
Good discussion though. :-)
Sorry if I came off too strong. I didn't mean to be.
I don't see any reason people can't use science to their benefit if they are trying to conceive.
I am also pro-choice. I am NOT pro-abortion. I would never do it myself and I don't believe in using abortion as a form of birth control. BUT I don't think the government should be able to tell women what they can and can't do with their bodies.
I currently have a friend who has conceived one child naturally, and has tried so hard for the last 3 years to conceive again. She's done the hormone shots, etc to "help" her body become ready to accept artificial insemination. Time and time I read her blog to see her hopes get high and then fall with another failed treatment. It's really and truly heartbreaking - and because I'm not one of those people, I think to myself "Why not just adopt?"
I KNOW that adoption isn't what "those" people want to hear. They want to have children of their own. The other day, I read her blog again and she'd written that she was pregnant... and within 24 hours again, she posted that her body began losing that pregnancy as well. My heart went out to her, but I couldn't help but think "if God wanted it to be, it would be..."
God blessed you Cass! Congratulations on your little miracle pulling through. I do believe in the aid of science, but I'm also a FIRM believer that God is the final judgement in all things.
"if God wanted it to be, it would be..."
I'm sorry but this really offends me. I just lost my baby last week. It had nothing to do with God, the dr said sometimes the egg and sperm just don't form together right. I don't believe in God so if you told me something like this I would be pretty annoyed. If your friend can handle it mentally and physically then I see no reason why she shouldn't keep trying. I love my child because she is a part of me I just don't think it would be the same if I adopted. Not saying there is anything wrong with adopting or that people that adopt don't love their children as much as me. That just isn't for me and it sounds like it isn't for your friend either.
I have a know someone right now who is considering looking for a sperm donor who looks like the husband and they would do IVF. She has been told it would be like cheating on her husband, that God decided she shouldn't have kids, and that its just not right from her Christian friends all around. She said that all of these things hurt her deeply to hear them and all she can really hear is that God has blessed them and punished her. She takes no comfort in the words.
I think support and a good hug help more than someones opinion that God won't let them have kids. There is nothing wrong with "My heart goes out to you" and leaving "Gods will" (which we have NO IDEA what it is!) out of it.
M'lissa, I hope things work out for you!
What kills me about the God thing is it take an amazing gift to be able to invent IVF. The Dr's that do this with success are truly amazing. Countless gifts are given to Dr's who can miraculously save tiny premie babies. Still others are given gift of inventing the equipment it takes to keep these precious babies with us. This sounds just as much to me as a gift from God as conceiving and having a full term baby naturally. Just like you said Cass how do we know what's God will is.
M'lissa, I too am truly sorry for your loss. I meant no harm in stating my "opinions" and beliefs here in a controversial debate. It isn't to spark a war of words, but merely to gather a broad spectrum of thoughts on a subject. I don't think anyone here is trying to persuade one person to believe ONLY their thoughts or to try to force their opinions on anyone else because theirs is the only right opinion to believe.
Its a debate, in debating you can go back and forth on opinions and such. Its a nice debate, no fury behind the words as far as I can read. Strong opinions are just that, opinions. No one is attacking...its ok! :-)
Great job being civil everyone! LOL This is a touchy subject and its nice to everyone talking calmly about it. I once had a Psych teacher in college who was very proud of the fact that, when in college, he used to take women over to Mexico for late term abortions, we're talking after 6 mos, up to right before birth. He thought he was providing a great service to these young women... I suggested he would have done an even better service if he would have given them birth control in the first place! Whether or not one believes in God, abortion is murder in my opinion. Much more emphasis should be put on prevention. I am, honestly, though, not quite sure how I feel about the government making that decision for people. As bad as I think it is, I also feel it is a private matter. As far as trying to conceive through scientific means, I would personally not go past taking a mild fertility drug, as I am not equipped to deal with the option of multiples. But that is my personal choice... I do think that people often go too far in their efforts to have children, and that is coming from someone who has been on both sides of the issue. I've seen couples for whom having a baby becomes a sort of mania and they become so intent on trying to have one that they lose sight of other important things. As a Christian, I DO believe that some things should be left up to God, but with modern science, it can be very difficult to establsh that boundary. Ultimately, I think it just has to come down to personal choice and ones own limits. We don't have the right to tell people what those limits are for them, but we can hope they will use good judgment and a lot of soul searching.
I think it is easy to say what you "might" do if you couldn't have kids, but you don't really know until it happens. As far as abortions, I think that it is interesting that people always assume that a woman that is having and abortion must not have been preventing, half my friends have had children off BC.
I am personally not a religious person. I don't like when religion comes into these issues, I think god is in easy scapegoat. It's easy to say God means this and God wants that, when there is no way for anyone to know and you can basically say anything you want, no real facts. Sorry that is just my opinion.
My basic belief is that every single person is different and no one should have the right to tell anyone what they can and can't do with themselves. I mean there are tons of babies born to very unfit parents, you think God intended that?? Babies left in dumpsters and neglected Does not make sense to me when there are great people out there that can't have kids.God works in mysterious ways, is just an easy way to explain things that are unjust and unfair in life. I think if people really want kids and can afford it, then they should do whatever they need to. If God was there, he gave man the capacity to do these things.
I was going to stay out of this topic, but I feel like I should at least post this. I am absolutely pro-life, and think that every baby, from the time that they are conceived is a life. A beautiful precious life that should be cherished and respected. I have had two beautiful babies, and lost one, and while it was my body, in no way do I feel that would give me the right to take the life of another. Especially one that cannot speak for itself. I believe there is a true sanctity about life that should not be taken away.
abort73.com - Check it out.
On another note-I hope everyone is having a FANASTIC President's Day!
This is completely off the subject of conception/abortion... but I stumbled across a blog one day and I wanted to share it with you all... It's called Bring the Rain, the story of Audrey Caroline.
http://audreycaroline.blogspot.com.
Basically, Angie (the mother) found out early in her pregnancy that Audrey wasn't going to live. She might have been stillborn... The doctors gave her the option to abort, but she talked with God and decided to carry the child to term, always praying for the best. In the end, Audrey died shortly after birth. The blog is extremely beautiful, and very touching... Some people can't see the beauty in losing an infant in such a manner, but Angie is an AMAZINGLY gifted writer, and Christian... her faith is beyond words.
I'm not here to preach, but it's definitely a compelling blog to read.
I know that many people believe that life begins at conception, I personally don't but that is something else. However, I have one child and have miscarried two. I believe that babies are precious, however, I also feel I am very practical and realistic. What do we do with all these unwanted babies? There are many people that would like to adopt, but some can't and the orphanages are swollen with children that never find homes. Some are abandoned, abused and neglected. If a women does not want to have a child, and hopefully used protection, but lets be real there too, that is not always the case, she should not be forced to have it and if she is, what do we do with that baby? Everyone shouts adoption, but look at the realities of it, there are too many kids and not enough parents. And many children are removed from bad homes after infancy, making it harder to find adoptive parents. There is no easy answer, there are only the facts and that is what we have to deal with, not the what ifs or could be's. Reality isn't pretty, but until we can all look at what we have and come up with the best solution- might not be the one we want- but again, that's not the way it works- we will never fix the real issues, whether it is abortion, health care or global warming. - Again just my opinion.
I didn't mean for my post to come off as rude either if it did I am sorry DJ. I have just heard a lot of ignorant things about mc lately. People don't know what to say and say the first thing that comes to mind, which comes off as wrong usually. At the moment it is a very touchy subject.
I've been there, we lost twins at 19 weeks (second pregancy) which then decided that I had incompetant cervix. They also died shortly after birth. To me personally, there was no beauty in it. That women was given a long time of knowing what might happen so to me, to find any "beauty" in it, was more that she made peace with it. I would have never chosen abortion should I have ever known what was going to happen in the begining but I would never take that choice from someone else or think they made the wrong choice.
How can another human condemn someone else a murderer if this women had chosen abortion in the start of her pregnancy? Some women are not strong enough to face having to watch their child/children die before them.
But then again, maybe I would have the same opinions as those with an unwavering view on abortion if I had not been through what I went through.
Melissa, I totally agree. Its not an easy way to look at it.
Look at it from this point. A 9 year old girl was raped by her step father. She concieved twins by him. A lot of doctors agreed the birth would kill her so they performed an abortion. The Catholic church then condemned the girl, the doctors and her mother for allowing the abortion to happen. Did they condemn the pedophile? Nope. What choice did that girl have? A life barely lived only to be raped and then die in childbirth? Somethings are not so black and white.
I will say that while I am absolutely pro-life and believe that every child deserves a chance at life (I do understand your points Melissaa, and I DO absolutely believe the system is broken), I would also absolutely never condemn a woman who made the choice to have an abortion. I truly think every woman who has made the choice to have one still deserves to be loved whether I believe it was the right choice or not.
CassinEngland-I can't imagine how horrible that must have been. And while I'm so sad that you lost your sweet babies, I'm also glad you were blessed with an amazing miracle. Sounds like you have a sweet baby boy!
In October of 2004, we were shocked to find out I was pregnant (and while on BC AND breastfeeding!!!). From the beginning it was touch and go. At 8 weeks I started miscarrying the baby. I was sent home from the hospital and told that the pregnancy would be over soon. That next Monday I went to my doctor. Lo and behold there was a happy little baby, strong heartbeat and all. The placenta had torn partly away. Apparently, the "miscarriage" simply stopped and the baby continued to live. At 18 weeks I had the "BIG" ultrasound. We left that appointment dazed and very confused. I had no amniotic fluid. From that point on we were told our baby had less than 10% of a chance to live. It would be best to end the pregnancy. I was in and out of the hospital. I was ALWAYS at the doctor's office. They never could put their finger on exactly what was wrong with our sweet baby girl. We chose to place her life in God's hands. We prayed fervently for her.
In the end, at 33 weeks they took her by c-section because she was no longer growing. She had a condition called Potter's Syndrome (absence of the kidneys). She spent four precious hours with us.
It sucked ---- BAD!! But I wouldn't change how things went. Her life was not mine. I could not decide before hand that she would live or die. As much as it hurts to see your child leave this Earth, I cannot imagine the pain of choosing to end your child's life.
When we felt that we were ready to have another baby we tried and tried to get pregnant. I would get pregnant and lose the baby within a week. Finally, it was decided that I needed a course of fertility drugs in addition to other medications. It was awful month after month hearing I wasn't pregnant. At one point I did get pregnant, and like the others I lost it as well. Finally on the 6th round of treatments, after many, many nights in prayer, we decided that would be the last treatment. I couldn't do it anymore. Those meds are not fun, and can turn you into a mean, mean person!! Sure enough it worked....and we hit our knees and prayed for that baby to live. My levels in the past would rise and then fall dramatically. This time they were quadrupling. Scared me to death to think I might be carrying multiples! But instead I was carrying another healthy baby girl! In spite of my history of bed rest and trying pregnancies, her pregnancy was perfect! The only problem I had was she wanted out a little early (35 weeks).
I can't imagine not caring about the babies that grew within my womb (6 total --- 2 live children, 1 infant death, 3 miscarriages). I love each and every one of them. I don't understand how a woman, regardless of her situation, can disregard her child's life. It seems so against the grain of womanhood.
Thanks for sharing Gina. Your story sounds so much like the one I followed on the blog I posted a link to.
I was very blessed with two healthy pregnancies, and found out last Tuesday that we are now pregnant with a third. I pray daily for the health of this last child! I can't imagine going through anything other than a normal pregnancy.
As much as government and science butt their noses into personal fairs, I don't think I could ever not believe that God is the final say in all things living... for science might create an embryo by joining a sperm and an egg... but only God can breathe life into a newborn baby :)
There was another DJ at the lunch? Aww man, and here I thought I was one of the few :)
No, I didn't post on the intro thread... didn't really see the need to make myself publicly known. I figured if people wanted to know me for me, they'd send me a personal message.
DJ --- I just finished reading part of her blog (especially her letter to her daughter) and I am bawling!! I had to email her because of the similarity of what we went through.
I'm glad you took the time Gina... sometimes it helps for people in similar situations to relate.
She wrote a book, available for pre-order on Amazon and I DO plan on buying it! It's called I Will Carry You.
I bawled when I saw the slideshow of the pictures taken at the hospital the day Audrey was born. I think I was more overcome by the incredible strength during such a time of deep sorrow. So hard for a mother to smile at a dying child :( but she went on living with such a profound faith.
I know I'm not at ALL experienced in the losses you have both suffered, but if you ever need a listening ear, I'd be more than willing.