Is there really a problem with that? I had no idea... Of course I was one of those that kept my daughter in a four point harness until she was four, and only stopped because it wouldn't fit anymore. lol
I'm all about keeping kids in their carseats until they outgrow them and then putting them into boosters. My oldest is almost four, and he's still in his 5 point harness seat. It fits up to 65lb (it turns into a booster also) or until his shoulders are too tall, and he'll be in the 5 point until he's too tall. When it comes to safety of our little ones, I think it's so important!
My sister pointed out to me today that my son is too big for his infant carseat even though he is not a year. So I will have to use a rear facing carseat that will eventually be turned forward when he is one year. I just figured that he could be in his infant seat until he was a year. The seats have a weight limit and he just hit it. I just thought I would throw that out there since we were discussing safety seats.
I have a convertible one and we were using it but then we switched to the infant seat. I guess we will be switching back. I did notice. It is a pretty pink!
we put Ava in the forward facing one way too early... but shes's 2 now - never been in an accident with either kid *knock on wood* and the oldest is 7.
My 7 yr old is in a booster now though.
DeAnna-
I hope you will reconsider turning him forward at 1 year. The AAP and mayo clinic have changed their min. recommendation to 2 years. The 1 year and 20 pounds is now just the bare minimum. My daughter is almost 3 and I have her still rear facing. These sites have some awesome information about it.
http://www.freewebs.com/sacredjourneys/newbornpreschool.htm
http://www.kyledavidmiller.org/pages/home/index.htm
I did hear about that Becca and to me it seem like it would be quite uncomfortable for the kiddo to have his legs curled up against the backseat but it would prevent them from kicking the back of your seat while you are driving!
What is hard is handing my booster to another mom when our child is riding with them and them looking at me like I am on crack. Or their child getting upset that I put them in one.
Kristen I hope that you weren't trying to say that because I choose to put my child in an appropriate seat that is forward facing(for his comfort) that I am jepordizing his safety. Please clarify.
It really isn't uncomfortable for them at all, in fact i think it's easier for her to sleep comfortably, and my daughter is tall for her age. When i got her new seat which can rear face to 45 pounds, i still had her old FF one in and she kept choosing the RF one. I mistakenly turned her FF at 1 year, but i have learned since that that was not a good decision. They are just so much safer that way. Especially from neck injuries which can be fatal. No documented cases of legs breaking while rear facing, but there are of necks breaking while forward facing. Such an easy thing to do to keep them safer longer.
FYI the Radian RF to 45 pounds now and FF with 5 point harness to 80 pounds.
I have to agree 100% with Becca on this! I also have a 2 year old that is rear facing still! I have been researching this for 2 years, and have talked to many car seat techs. Rear facing to the limits of the convertible seat is 5 times safer. The 1 year and 20 lbs. rule is just a minnimum, and my son is not a minimum. I am not saying you have to keep your child rear facing that long, as long as you keep them rear facing to the minimum (1 year AND 20 lbs.)! The AAP and car seat techs DO recommend keeping your kiddies rear facing longer though (2 years and 30 lbs at the least)! (: Atleast research it and make an informed decision!
No Deanna, sorry, I meant if my child on a booster has his legs cramped. Sorry, that was what one of the things that was put out there by a few moms I know with older kids use as their defense. I really don't know anything about carseats for younger kids anymore. They have changed a lot. Sorry if taken the wrong way.
I agree with Becca and April. My son is 3 and still rear-facing and comfortable. Even if he wasn't, his safety comes before anything else.
He would be even more uncomfortable if he had to have a Halo screwed into his head b/c of a broken neck.
www.joelsjourney.com. Joel was 18m old and FF and broke his neck in a minor collision. Had he been rear-facing this would have been prevented. Luckily his mom was able to import a seat from Sweeden to keep him rear-facing to 5 or 50lbs. :)
What is really sad is that the front gate does nothing to enforce it. I personally know of a guy who drove through the front gate with his twin 7 year olds in the back of his car that didnt even have back seats much less buckled in. There is no way they couldnt have seen it and they did nothing. It was a small car with a huge back window.
I remember going TDY to Turkey... I was appalled at the unfortunate mass of people there who drive erratically on EVERY road... high rates of speed, no regard for other drivers (I'm surprised I survived!) And the worst, was at every red light, I was beside someone who had a child in their lap. Back seat, front seat... no seat. Children on motorcycles with no helmet. Not everyone is informed I guess... I just felt so sad for these kids who knew nothing of the dangers they could face.
I guess I'm a horrible mother... Ava outgrew her infant carseat around 8 months... so we put her in a FF, 5 point carseat. Fortunately for ALL of us, we've never been involved in a collision. She's now 2, and 4 lbs shy of 30 lbs...
Not a horrible mother Jennifer, just ill informed of the dangers. Before I knew better my oldest was foward facing at 11m. Thank God he is okay. He is 7 and in a high back booster.
Now that I know better my younger 2 will be rear-facing until 4. Foward facing in a harness until 6 and boostered until they pass the 5-Step test.
I guess I'm just old fashioned... raised in a small town, where us kids sat on daddy's lap and steered the wheel while he pushed the pedals in the truck so we could drive!
I'm a firm believer in "sh!t happens." (that'll probably make me a horrible mother.) My kids are both in carseats, but I'm not going to rush out and turn Ava's around just because it's been studied by scientists and whoever else and supposedly confirmed to be safer.
I'm with DeAnna on comfort. It's so funny to look back and see Ava zonked out with her little feet propped up on the back of my seat, sprawled out in her carseat.
God forbid, we get in an accident and anything happens... but if it does, well... I took the precaution of having her in a carseat.
I won't OVER protect my children. We only have so long to prepare them for the real world, and well... as adults, we're prone to just as many dangers as they are as children. We can't lock ourselves away in some protective bubble in hopes that nothing is going to come along and pop it. You gotta get out there and learn how to walk on the sharp stuff! (if that makes sense.)
Okay I do not have kids yet but am pretty interested in all this that you all are talking about. I was looking at the info on http://www.aap.org/family/Carseatguide.htm
So you are all basically saying keep them REAR FACING as long as possible right?? Well most infant car seats weight max is 30lbs. GENERALLY speaking how old is a child that is 30lbs??
it's not supposedly confirmed, it's physics. I personally couldn't live with myself if I did not do everything in my power to protect my daughter. This is just an easy thing to do to give my daughter more protection in case of a major accident. to me that's not overprotecting it's the least i can do.
RoxAnne- They make convertible car seats, most of them rear face from 5-35 lbs. There is one that rear faces to 40-45 lbs. The convertible seats can go forward facing at 1 year and 20 lbs. but it is recommended to keep it rear facing to the limit of the seat. My 2 year old is only 29 lbs. now.
Well I have not really "searched" for them as I don't need one. I just like to to be informed for when the day does come YEARS from now LOL!
So basically, its based on weight NOT age correct!?